WHO IS THE MOST OVERRATED PLAYER IN BASEBALL?
Alex Rodriguez, Yankees 3B 18%
Joba Chamberlain, Yankees RP 12%
Derek Jeter, Yankees SS 7%
Jayson Werth, Nationals OF 4%
Jonathan Papelbon, Red Sox RP 4%
A-Rod and Chamberlain filled the top two slots in the same poll last year but in reverse order.... Yankees OF Nick Swisher also received 4% of the vote.... Of the top 14 active vote-getters, all but three play in Boston, Chicago or New York.... Combined, the five players above have made the All-Star Game in 57% of their seasons.
Based on 185 MLB players who responded to SI's survey
Facebook Fan Picks