Bob Goalby, 1968
The record book says Goalby, 39, edged Roberto De Vicenzo by a shot, but the two should have gone to a playoff. After completing his final round, De Vicenzo signed for a wrong score. He shot a 65 with a birdie 3 at 17, but his playing partner, Tommy Aaron, mistakenly put him down for a 4 on the hole, and a 66. Thus, De Vicenzo had to accept that score.
Goalby never contended in another major, but he did win three more Tour events, bringing his career total to 10. He and De Vicenzo have remained friends.
George Archer, 1969
After hitting his second shot at the par-5 15th into the greenside water hazard, the 30-year-old Archer pitched to 10 feet and made the par putt. That up and down preserved his one-shot victory over Billy Casper, George Knudson and Tom Weiskopf.
Archer had three other top 10s in majors, and he won 12 Tour events and 19 Champions tour titles over his long career.