SI Vault
 
THE MAIL
April 09, 2012
I can't believe that Colts owner Jim Irsay got rid of Peyton Manning and is going with a rookie. It doesn't matter how good Andrew Luck was at Stanford—this is still a recipe for disaster. Last season's dismal offense and 2--14 record prove that Indianapolis does not have the talent to win with an inexperienced quarterback.
Decrease font Decrease font
Enlarge font Enlarge font
April 09, 2012

The Mail

View CoverRead All Articles

I can't believe that Colts owner Jim Irsay got rid of Peyton Manning and is going with a rookie. It doesn't matter how good Andrew Luck was at Stanford—this is still a recipe for disaster. Last season's dismal offense and 2--14 record prove that Indianapolis does not have the talent to win with an inexperienced quarterback.

Al DiLascia, Chicopee, Mass.

A No-brainer

If I were an NFL owner, I would take Manning as my quarterback (Into the Great Unknown) over almost all of the other starters in the league, even if he was only 75% healthy. There is just no way you can pass on signing a guy with his talent. He has proved his worth as a winner by beating opponents with his mind as well as his arm.

P.B. Anderson, Memphis

Learning Curve

I wanted to clear up a bit of misinformation that was in your article on coach Ken Hitchcock and St. Louis (Mirth of the Blues). Hitchcock mentioned that his earliest hockey memory was in 1955, when at age four he watched Gordie Howe carry "a lefthanded stick, a stick that was the wrong way." While Howe may have carried his stick in his left hand, it could not have been a lefthanded stick. Curved blades did not appear in the NHL until the early 1960s, when the Blackhawks' Stan Mikita accidentally broke his stick in practice. Mikita thought the misshapen blade increased the power of his slap shots, so his teammates began curving their sticks and using them in games.

David Albanesi, Avon, Conn.

Tough Act to Follow

I've followed Antoine Walker (If Antoine Walker Shimmies, But It's in Boise, Is He Really Shimmying?) since his days at Kentucky. Yet after reading Chris Ballard's article about Walker's life in the NBA's Developmental League, I found I have no compassion for him. After all, this is a man who blew his $110 million in earnings. I empathize more with Walker's coach in Boise, Randy Livingston, a former NBA journeyman who was an amazing and humble athlete but who never reached his full potential as a player because of injuries.

Continue Story
1 2