SI Vault
 
MLB PLAYERS POLL
August 27, 2012
Who is the phoniest player in baseball?
Decrease font Decrease font
Enlarge font Enlarge font
August 27, 2012

Mlb Players Poll

View CoverRead All Articles

Who is the phoniest player in baseball?

ALEX RODRIGUEZ, YANKEES 3B 26%

NICK SWISHER, YANKEES RF 14%

NYJER MORGAN, BREWERS CF 11%

BRIAN WILSON, GIANTS P 9%

BRANDON PHILLIPS, REDS 2B 5%

FAST FACTS

Rodriguez was also voted the most overrated position player in the game (SI, July 9), while Swisher, Morgan, Wilson and Phillips were among the top six vote-getters for the distinction of baseball's most eccentric player (SI, Aug. 6).... The bulk of the votes for A-Rod (64%) came from players in the American League, and most of those (44%) came from his rivals in the AL East.

BASED ON THE RESPONSES OF 232 MLB PLAYERS TO SI'S SURVEY

1