SI Vault
 
The Case for the 49ers
Jim Trotter
January 14, 2013
The 49ers came within an overtime loss of reaching the Super Bowl last season, and they have the talent to go further this year. The questions confronting them, however, are more significant than a year ago, when they had a seasoned quarterback, a healthy defense and a kicker who was as dependable as a sunrise. None of those is the case entering Saturday's divisional round game against the Packers. Second-year quarterback Colin Kaepernick will be making his first postseason start; defensive end Justin Smith, a team captain and arguably the club's most valuable player, missed the final two-plus games with a partially torn triceps but is likely to play against Green Bay, although he could be limited by the injury; and David Akers has missed nearly as many field goal attempts this season (13) as he did in the previous two years combined (14).
Decrease font Decrease font
Enlarge font Enlarge font
January 14, 2013

The Case For The 49ers

View CoverRead All Articles

The 49ers came within an overtime loss of reaching the Super Bowl last season, and they have the talent to go further this year. The questions confronting them, however, are more significant than a year ago, when they had a seasoned quarterback, a healthy defense and a kicker who was as dependable as a sunrise. None of those is the case entering Saturday's divisional round game against the Packers. Second-year quarterback Colin Kaepernick will be making his first postseason start; defensive end Justin Smith, a team captain and arguably the club's most valuable player, missed the final two-plus games with a partially torn triceps but is likely to play against Green Bay, although he could be limited by the injury; and David Akers has missed nearly as many field goal attempts this season (13) as he did in the previous two years combined (14).

Kaepernick has had flashes of brilliance coupled with bouts of inconsistency since taking over as the starter in a Nov. 19 win over the Bears. Coach Jim Harbaugh made the change in part because he felt he had seen the best of Alex Smith and wasn't sure it was enough to win a title. The Nevada product is a more dynamic runner than Smith, and for all of Vikings QB Joe Webb's passing struggles against Green Bay in the wild-card round, he showed that a running quarterback can cause problems for the Pack—he tore off four runs of 10 yards or more in Green Bay. Kaepernick is a similar threat: in his last eight games he had 10 carries of at least 10 yards and 14 rushes for first downs. He's also a bigger threat in the vertical passing game than Smith (and certainly than Webb), completing 21 pass plays of at least 25 yards, 10 more than Smith had in his nine games before being benched. What's more, though Kaepernick may not bring playoff experience, he has big-game seasoning, with wins at New England and New Orleans, as well as against Chicago—in those games he had seven TD passes and one rushing score, with just two turnovers. "One of the things that stood out about Colin from the very start was the poise," says Harbaugh, "that he was able to handle situations like a guy who looks like he's been playing that position for a long time."

Justin Smith is as vital on defense. He didn't put up eye-popping numbers in 2012, but his ability to stop the run and command double teams in passing situations created opportunities for teammates—outside linebacker Aldon Smith had 19½ sacks through 13 games but had zero over the final 2½ games when Justin Smith was sidelined. Moreover, the defense has surrendered 79 points over its last 10 quarters without Justin Smith after allowing barely 14 points a game before his injury.

A recovered Justin Smith, an effective Aldon Smith and an efficient Kaepernick could reverse that trend versus the Packers—but the 49ers still need Akers to deliver. The 38-year-old was money last season, converting on 44 of 52 field goal attempts. This season he was 29 of 42 with at least one miss in six of his last eight games (inspiring the Niners to sign Billy Cundiff last week as insurance). The question now: Which Akers will the Niners get—the one who was 4 for 4 in the postseason last year, or the one who missed from 41 and 34 yards in the Eagles' 21--16 loss to the Packers two years ago in the playoffs?

1