College Football Straight Up Picks for Every Top 25 Week 9 Game

Reed Wallach | 3 Hours Ago

Oct 19, 2024; Atlanta, Georgia, USA; Notre Dame Fighting Irish quarterback Riley Leonard (13) scrambles against the Georgia Tech Yellow Jackets in the fourth quarter at Mercedes-Benz Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Brett Davis-Imagn Images / Brett Davis-Imagn Images

There are plenty of marquee matchups in Week 9 that will help determine the College Football Playoff race, some of which are surprising.

Navy and Notre Dame will meet at MetLife Stadium on Saturday afternoon in a game that can be the catalyst for a Navy CFP run or the beginning of Notre Dame's re-emergence as a top-12 threat. The Fighting Irish can't afford another upset loss, can the team get past an upstart Midshipmen team?

We got you covered with picks for every Top 25 matchup on the Week 9 slate.

Odds courtesy of FanDuel Sportsbook

Season Record 88-33

Best College Football Picks for Week 9

Syracuse vs. Pittsburgh Prediction and Pick

Pick: Syracuse +172

While this game should be full of points, I don’t believe the difference between these teams is as great as the point spread indicates.

The Orange have been frisky as an underdog this season, winning both games outright, and are being undervalued against a Pitt defense that is outside the top in EPA/Pass this season.

That should set up nicely for Kyle McCord and the Syracuse offense that is 32nd in EPA/Play.

The Panthers are undefeated, but its four wins against Power Four competition have been by a combined 17 points.

The Orange are live on Thursday night.

Boise State vs. UNLV Prediction and Pick

Pick: UNLV +130

Nebraska vs. Ohio State Prediction and Pick

Pick: Ohio State -4500

Notre Dame vs. Navy Prediction and Pick

Pick: Notre Dame -480

While Navy has a lot of hype as an undefeated team, the group has faced only one team inside the top 100 in EPA/Play and has yet to face one inside the top 40 in EPA/Play on defense.

Notre Dame is both of those things. I believe the Irish can name its number in this contest with its ability to punish a soft Midshipmen defensive line that is bottom 20 in defensive line yards this season with its blistering run game that is top 10 in yards per carry at nearly six yards per rush.

On a neutral field, there will be no upset on Saturday afternoon and the Fighting Irish can notch a resume-building win against the triple option team.

Washington vs. Indiana Prediction and Pick

Pick: Washington +190

Oklahoma vs. Ole Miss Prediction and Pick

Pick: Ole Miss -1700

Illinois vs. Oregon Prediction and Pick

Pick: Oregon -2000

BYU vs. UCF Prediction and Pick

Pick: UCF -111

Missouri vs. Alabama Prediction and Pick

Pick: Alabama -550

Texas vs. Vanderbilt Prediction and Pick

Pick: Texas -1100

Florida State vs. Miami (Florida) Prediction and Pick

Pick: Miami (Florida): -1450

Penn State vs. Wisconsin Prediction and Pick

Pick: Penn State -250

LSU vs. Texas A&M Prediction and Pick

Pick: Texas A&M -140

I think this is a great opportunity to sell LSU at its highest.

While the Tigers are winners of six straight games, including two in a row out of its BYE week, let’s take a deeper dive at those games.

The Bayou Bengals beat a banged-up Ole Miss team in overtime that was playing its seventh straight game and an Arkansas team that was far from full strength on the road. Now, the team gets a healthy Texas A&M team that will be its toughest test of the season on both the offensive and defensive line.

Texas A&M is more vulnerable in the secondary, bottom half of the country in coverage grading per Pro Football Focus, but with LSU’s lack of a ground game, the Aggies may be able to drop more defenders into coverage to slow down this LSU passing attack.

LSU is passing at a top 10 rate, which makes the team easier to figure out and tips the scales toward head coach Mike Elko in terms of conceiving a game plan to slow down LSU.

Meanwhile, the Tigers' defense has improved but is still 84th in EPA/Play. I believe the team’s inability to get off the field on third down, 110th in third down success rate, will play a big role in determining this game. For what it’s worth, Texas A&M is tied for the 19th-best third-down success rate and can create more scoring chances.

Kansas vs. Kansas State Prediction and Pick

Pick: Kansas State -335

SMU vs. Duke Prediction and Pick

Pick: SMU -465