College Football Playoff Bracket Week 9 Projections: How Will Committee View the Chaos?

In this story:
Update at 11 p.m. ET Saturday
The College Football Playoff selection committee meets for the first time next week and they could probably be forgiven for just turning right around and saying, “No, thank you,” when faced with the task at hand.
That’s seemingly the nature of this season, where somebody you think is a good team follows up a big win with a head-scratching loss and résumés are much more of a jumbled mess than clean and straightforward. Trying to figure out who really is playoff worthy? Well, outside of a very select number of programs, that truly is in the eye of the beholder in 2026.
Take the Big Ten for example. Is Indiana good? Well you kind of think the reigning national champions are because they have Curt Cignetti scowling on the sideline and guys like Charlie Becker making ridiculous catches and seemingly a kicker capable of making a field goal from the moon. But they’ve now won two straight games in overtime against teams they really should have beaten much more easily and even the head coach is making questionable decisions with clock management down the stretch. Up is down and down is up, I guess.
Then there’s Ohio State, the normal team you would pencil in as the league’s best. The Buckeyes have two losses which aren’t bad on paper—both on the road to quality teams—but have to be viewed in a new light because of how iffy they looked against USC. And what even are the Trojans, who are now 1–1 against backup quarterbacks and somehow couldn’t score on Wisconsin that got run out of the building by Iowa on Saturday. UCLA is undefeated but also has a backup quarterback on the field plus a résumé that is paper thin beyond a victory over an Oregon squad which is up and down this season.
Go ahead and figure out a pecking order for that group and then factor in the SEC. Georgia and Kentucky are the only one-loss teams and six more programs are hoping for some set of tiebreakers to land them a spot in Atlanta for the last conference title game. How will the committee weigh Alabama beating the Wildcats, but completely dropping the ball in a loss to Tennessee, or Texas beating a full-strength Ohio State, thumping Ole Miss and yet looking otherwise middling (including against Mississippi State tonight despite that final scoreline). Toss in some Big 12 chaos and the general ACC malaise and the committee will have its work cut out for it.
No metric can serve as a guiding light this season. No résumé debate will be clean and straightforward based on what we’ve seen in 2026. This season is a mess and that’s precisely why you tend to love this sport, for an entertainment product unlike any other.
The committee’s Top 25 is looking like an impossible task after a weekend that did no favors in trying to make sense of everything by Tuesday.
Update at 8 p.m. ET Saturday
The sun is down, it’s Halloween and there have been some scary results for plenty of teams in CFP contention this Saturday. That included a statement being sent by Georgia against its rival Florida, an incredible comeback that didn’t lack for drama by Indiana to remain in the thick of the Big Ten race and notable results across the rest of the Power 4 that saw teams rip off their masks to show us who they truly are. Given the prime-time games on tap, the bracket should see plenty more movement in the coming hours as the sun goes down fully and the tricks and treats will not be reserved only for the kids in costumes across the country.
Update at noon ET Saturday
It’s the last chance for teams to make an impression on the College Football Playoff selection committee ahead of the first Top 25 rankings reveal on Tuesday. Style points and big wins will be key for a number of programs this weekend as the national title chase gets kicked into overdrive on the way to Las Vegas. This Saturday doesn’t quite have the blockbuster matchups that are on tap for next week, but that typically doesn’t stop chaos from striking in this sport and consequently allow for plenty of teams to play themselves into (and out of) the field.
With that in mind, here’s how the bracket looks going into Week 9 before it’s set to shift significantly throughout a busy Saturday in the sport.
Live Week 9 College Football Playoff Bracket
- Miami
- Georgia
- Utah
- UCLA
- Indiana
- Kentucky
- BYU
- Notre Dame
- Alabama
- Mississippi
- Ohio State
- Boise State
First Round
- No. 12 Boise State at No. 5 Indiana
- No. 11 Ohio State at No. 6 Kentucky
- No. 10 Mississippi at No. 7 BYU
- No. 9 Alabama at No. 8 Notre Dame
Quarterfinals
- Rose Bowl: No. 4 UCLA vs. winner of No. 12 Boise State vs. No. 5 Indiana
- Fiesta Bowl: No. 3 Utah vs. winner of No. 11 Ohio State vs. No. 6 Kentucky
- Cotton Bowl: No. 2 Georgia vs. winner of No. 10 Mississippi vs. No. 7 BYU
- Peach Bowl: No. 1 Miami vs. winner of No. 9 Alabama vs. No. 8 Notre Dame
No. 12 Boise State at No. 5 Indiana
Kellen Moore returns to the blue turf for the unveiling of his statue at the school, and he’ll need some of his magic to rub off on the current team as it faces a very tough test against new Pac-12 foe Texas State. As for the Hoosiers, is it better to be lucky than good? Last year they were certainly both, but after surviving yet again by the skin of their teeth in overtime against Minnesota, you have to wonder if all these close calls will catch up with Cignetti & Co. at some point to prevent a return to the Big Ten title game.
No. 11 Ohio State at No. 6 Kentucky
Oh, what to make of the Buckeyes after they couldn’t get anything done on defense, special teams or with the best player in the country in Jeremiah Smith? While there was much attention paid to new QB Luke Fahey, that sure didn’t seem like the only reason Ohio State lost on the road to USC. Now the Buckeyes will be perhaps the most interesting team for the committee to sort out, with one of the best wins in the country (at Indiana), but two incredibly head-scratching losses away from home. They could be in the playoff picture or they could be firmly out of it when Tuesday rolls around. The Wildcats are off this weekend but will have plenty of interest in Tuesday’s committee rankings to see just where they might end up ranked amid this incredible year in Lexington, Ky.
No. 10 Mississippi at No. 7 BYU
The Rebels have jumped into and out of CFP contention but finally clicked into gear during the second half against Auburn. They have a chance to all but lock up a bid and even the inside track for Atlanta if they can top Georgia in Oxford, Miss., next weekend. As for the Cougars, they didn’t seem exactly crisp in terms of their execution against Arizona State as they attempted to bounce back from the first loss of the season. Were they looking ahead to the Holy War up the road in Salt Lake City? They have to hope that’s the case.
No. 9 Alabama at No. 8 Notre Dame
The Crimson Tide will be well rested for their game next week against LSU in what is more or less their last big test in the stretch run as they remain alive to make it back to Atlanta for another crack at the SEC title game. The Fighting Irish, on the other hand, looked like they were already focused on their upcoming home game against Miami early on against Navy, before eventually making some halftime tweaks to take care of business against the Midshipmen. Marcus Freeman will still need to do something to inject some life into this Notre Dame team before kickoff next week though, because these slow starts have a chance to really doom them against better competition. Throw in losses by SMU and Wisconsin and Notre Dame’s CFP chances may really come directly down to beating the Hurricanes at home.
Rose Bowl: No. 4 UCLA
On a day where plenty of teams faltered, got stuck in a close game or even wound up falling to an unranked opponent, credit to the Bruins for taking care of business against an overmatched Nevada. There are some tricky spots coming up but you really can’t rule out a trip to Indianapolis for the Big Ten title game at this point given the schedule that is ahead for one of the three remaining undefeated teams.
Fiesta Bowl: No. 3 Utah
After going into Cincinnati and ensuring the tricky spot on the road was nothing but a bit of light exercise, this Utah team sure looks like the one to beat in the Big 12 right now. It will be interesting to see where the committee has the Utes in its first rankings as they’ve more than passed the eye test, even if they don’t have a slew of marquee wins—one of which could be on hand next Saturday against BYU.
Cotton Bowl: No. 2 Georgia
It was a different environment for the World’s Largest Cocktail Party in Atlanta but the same dominating defense and efficient offense you come to expect out of the Bulldogs. That rivalry win not only should put some wind back in Georgia’s sails, but the manner it just dominated Florida seems like yet another message that this is one of the firm national title favorites.
Peach Bowl: No. 1 Miami
They never said being No. 1 is easy and there were times against North Carolina where it felt like the Hurricanes were intentionally giving their fans a heart attack. Alas, a win on the road against a Bill Belichick–coached team doesn’t need style points as attention can now turn to the looming meeting against Notre Dame in the biggest game since the original Catholics vs. Convicts. Miami is likely O.K. even if it doesn’t win that, but given how down the ACC looks it should be taking no chances given how chaotic the sport seems to be this season.
PODCAST: Listen to Sports Illustrated’s college sports podcast, Others Receiving Votes, hosted by Pat Forde, on Apple and Spotify. Watch the show on SI’s college YouTube channel or on SI TV.

Bryan Fischer is a staff writer at Sports Illustrated covering college sports. He joined the SI staff in October 2024 after spending nearly two decades at outlets such as FOX Sports, NBC Sports and CBS Sports. A member of the Football Writers Association of America’s All-America Selection Committee and a Heisman Trophy voter, Fischer has received awards for investigative journalism from the Associated Press Sports Editors and FWAA. He has a bachelor’s in communication from USC.
Follow bryandfischer