NFL analyst says Shedeur Sanders isn't a lock as a first-rounder in 2025

Colorado's standout quarterback goes into pre-draft period with many questioning his skillset

Troy Taormina-Imagn Images

Shedeur Sanders continues to captivate the sports world with his decision to forgo attending the 2025 NFL Draft ceremony in Green Bay. Instead, Sanders plans to host his own event in Boulder, Colorado, marking his transition from college football to the NFL in a way that reflects his personality and connection to Buffs Nation.

While the specifics of the event remain under wraps, Sanders’ choice mirrors the trend of athletes embracing unique, personal milestones, much like Terrell Owens did during his Hall of Fame induction at the University of Tennessee at Chattanooga. This decision speaks volumes about Sanders’ desire to honor his collegiate journey and maintain a connection with the fans who supported him throughout his career.

Sanders, often referred to by his nickname “Grown,” has demonstrated a keen understanding of media dynamics, a skill undoubtedly passed down from his father, Deion Sanders. As a Hall of Famer and Sanders’ head coach at Colorado, he has consistently taught his sons to control their narratives and remain at the forefront of public attention. This strategic approach keeps Shedeur in the spotlight, generating intrigue and debate as the draft approaches. The rise of NIL deals has significantly altered college football’s landscape, empowering athletes to forge their own paths even as they prepare to enter professional leagues. Sanders’ draft party could potentially set a precedent for future athletes, encouraging them to celebrate milestones alongside their collegiate communities.

Top three of 2025 NFL Draft set — Where does Travis Hunter and Shedeur Sanders fit?

Despite his impressive collegiate stats, Sanders faces skepticism from NFL scouts. His performance during his final game against BYU, where he completed 15 of 23 passes for 208 yards, two touchdowns, and two interceptions, drew mixed reviews. While Sanders boasts a remarkable 74% completion rate and passed for 4,134 yards during the season, analysts point to the number of sacks and hits he endured as potential red flags. Some praise his resilience and willingness to stand in the pocket under pressure, while others criticize his hesitation to throw the ball away. This dual narrative has fueled ongoing debates about his draft stock, with contrasting opinions emerging across the NFL landscape.

One of the more notable critiques came from NFL Network’s Tom Pelissero, who stated on The Rich Eisen Show on Friday that some within the league do not grade Sanders as a first-round prospect. This assertion has sparked widespread discussion among fans and analysts, questioning the evaluative criteria scouts use. Some argue that Sanders’ raw talent and production should outweigh concerns about his pocket presence or sack numbers. However, the NFL Draft is often dictated by team needs, and franchises might prioritize positions like offensive tackle before considering quarterbacks. Sanders’ ability to perform during his Pro Day will be crucial in silencing doubters and showcasing the full range of his abilities.

Colorado's Shedeur Sanders loses top spot on NIL valuation list

For Sanders, all it takes is one team to recognize his potential and offer him an opportunity. His leadership, competitive spirit, and playmaking ability make him a compelling prospect for any organization seeking a dynamic quarterback. As the draft draws nearer, the scrutiny surrounding Sanders will only intensify, but his confidence and unwavering belief in his skills could ultimately propel him to success. Whether he hears his name called in the first round or later, Sanders’ journey to the NFL will undoubtedly be one to watch, and his impact on the game will likely extend far beyond draft night.