The Black Head Coach: Nine NFL Openings, But No Hires - Why?

The NFL has many black qualified previous head and assistant coaches, nine open positions, so why haven't any been hired?

I am a fan of the NFL. Like you, I watch the games, and I cheer for my favorite team. So that you will know, my favorite NFL team is the New Orleans Saints.

The Saints didn't make the playoffs this year. I hope we'll have better luck next year.

Each year in the National Football League, coaches are hired and fired. This is because of the axiom, "the thrill of victory and the agony of defeat." If you don't win in the NFL, your tenure might be short.

Instagram Post 1080x1080 px - YouTube Thumbnail (1)

However, that statement is not always true. Tony Dungy, former coach of the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, had a winning record, yet he was fired in 2001 by Malcolm Glazer.

It is my opinion that the owners have the power in the NFL. That is no secret.

Nine head coaching positions were available.  Today, we are down to three.  Not one black coach hired, yet.  Why?

The NFL Commissioner, Roger Goodell, was hired by the owners. Coaches and players have no say in who is hired. It is not a popularity contest.

There are 32 teams in the NFL. Ownership is coveted and exclusive. It is a club where you must have certain qualifications. Of course, being rich is one of them.

We can only opine as to what other credentials you must have. Currently, there are no African American owners in the National Football League. Will that change over time? I hope so.

As we approach the Super Bowl, Mike Tomlin of the Pittsburgh Steelers is the only Black head coach in the league. He's won a Super Bowl title and has never had a losing season. That's impressive.

Approximately 70% of the players in the NFL are Black, so why is there only one Black head coach? The question of not having more Black head coaches has been at the goal line for years.

The National Football League has tried to do something about it, but have they done enough? It depends on who you ask and whether they are inside or outside the organization. 

I don't think they have done enough. I am on the outside looking inside.

The Rooney Rule was adopted in 2003 and named after then owner, Dan Rooney of the Pittsburgh Steelers. He was also chairman of the league's diversity committee.

The Rooney Rule requires that every team with a head coaching vacancy interview at least one diverse candidate. Since 2009, it has also included general manager jobs and executive leadership positions in the front office.

More African American candidates have been interviewed, so there has been some success. Anthony Lynn (Chargers), Vance Joseph (Broncos), and Steve Wilks (Cardinals) were hired and since fired. Black men like Eric Bieniemy (Chiefs), Byron Leftwich (Buccaneers), and Jim Caldwell (former head coach of the Lions) are receiving interviews to become head coaches. 

We'll see what happens.

As we know, Brian Flores, former coach of the Miami Dolphins, has filed a class-action lawsuit against the NFL and three of its teams. They are the Miami Dolphins, New York Giants, and the Denver Broncos. Brian Flores is African American.

The main parts of his lawsuit accuse the teams of sham interviews, incentivizing losses, and improperly recruiting players. These allegations are bringing shockwaves throughout the National Football League.

In an NFL memo, Roger Goodell said, "We have made significant efforts to promote diversity and adopted numerous policies and programs which have produced positive change in many areas. However, we must acknowledge that particularly concerning head coaches, the results have been unacceptable."

He added, "We will reevaluate and examine all policies, guidelines, and initiatives relating to diversity, equity, and inclusion, including as they relate to gender."

These pronouncements come on the heels of African American pro football hires. Hampton University alumnus Sashi Brown has been named the president of the Baltimore Ravens. He was formerly the president of the NBA's Washington Wizards. Also, former Chargers head coach Anthony Lynn accepted the position as an assistant coach with the San Francisco 49ers.

I find the timing of these announcements interesting. That's just me.

Brian Flores said, "it's hard to speak out. It is. You're making some sacrifices, but this is bigger than football and coaching."

Football fans will see whether Brian Flores will ever be employed again as a head coach in the National Football League in the coming weeks.

He's right. This is bigger than football.

HBCU Sports Coverage


Published
James B. Ewers Jr, Ed.D.
JAMES B. EWERS JR, ED.D.

Dr. James B. Ewers Jr. is a guest contributor of HBCU Legends.  Dr. Ewers graduated from Johnson C. Smith University located in Charlotte, NC. He was All-CIAA for 4 years and holds the school record for having won 34 consecutive tennis singles matches. He is a member of their Hall of Fame. He is an author and consultant. Dr. Ewers is a member of The Black Tennis Hall of Fame.