Is plausible deniability Michigan's defense in light of new sign stealing information?
![Jim Harbaugh is leaving Michigan to become head coach of the Los Angeles Chargers. Jim Harbaugh is leaving Michigan to become head coach of the Los Angeles Chargers.](https://images2.minutemediacdn.com/image/upload/c_crop,w_1564,h_879,x_333,y_17/c_fill,w_720,ar_16:9,f_auto,q_auto,g_auto/images/ImagnImages/mmsport/wolverine_digest/01jjsp5se0v3a33hcs8x.jpg)
The Michigan football program finds itself once again embroiled in controversy over the Conor Stalions sign-stealing scandal. With the NCAA now alleging six Level I violations, this situation can no longer be dismissed or ignored by fans, the athletic department, or university leadership. The gravity of these allegations is underscored by the alleged knowledge of multiple coaches, who are named in the NCAA’s documents as being aware of, or complicit in, the scheme in some capacity. Among those named are Mike Hart, Jesse Minter, Chris Partridge, and current Head Coach Sherrone Moore. These revelations challenge the previously held narrative that Stalions acted alone and without the knowledge of his superiors.
In a 137-page response to the NCAA obtained by @YahooSports, Michigan intends to fight allegations of the Stalions scheme, accuses NCAA of overreaching, defends Sherrone Moore’s deleted texts & reveals that the original NCAA tip came from its own campushttps://t.co/RsDlAnBdKz
— Ross Dellenger (@RossDellenger) January 28, 2025
The coaches in question, however, are asserting that they believed Stalions was operating within the confines of NCAA rules and regulations. This defense of “plausible deniability” raises significant questions about the extent of the coaching staff’s awareness and involvement in the situation. Can the defense of not actively engaging in the sign-stealing process hold water in an investigation of this magnitude? Is it realistic to believe that coaches, especially those at the coordinator level, were unaware of the methods being employed to gain a competitive edge? Furthermore, if Stalions' activities were indeed known to coaches below Jim Harbaugh, but not the head coach himself, does that absolve Harbaugh and the program from direct culpability?
These are critical questions that will shape the direction of the investigation, and there is no clear answer at this stage. One thing is certain, however: the NCAA, once a powerful regulatory body with the ability to enforce harsh sanctions, has seen its authority diminish in recent years. The organization has struggled to win many cases in civilian courts, casting doubt on its ability to impose meaningful consequences that could affect Michigan or its powerful alumni base.
Michigan, as a brand, carries significant weight both within the world of college football and beyond. The university has a large and influential alumni network that could provide both financial and legal support in what promises to be a prolonged and contentious battle. The stakes are high for the program, and it’s clear that this scandal will not be resolved quickly. With multiple parties involved, differing accounts of knowledge and involvement, and the backdrop of a weakened NCAA, this is a situation that could drag on for months or even years.
At this point, it remains to be seen how the investigation will unfold, and whether the NCAA will be able to impose any meaningful sanctions. The ultimate question is whether Michigan’s legal and public relations resources will be enough to mount a successful defense or if this scandal will become a long-running saga for the university. Regardless of the outcome, the damage to the program’s reputation and the shadow it casts over the2023 championship season will undoubtedly be felt for some time to come.
Enjoy more Michigan Wolverines coverage on Michigan Wolverines On SI -
More Michigan News:
Michigan football trending away from top transfer offensive line target
ESPN predicts a major season from Michigan football in 2025
Mock Draft Monday 1.0: Where Michigan football players are predicted to go in '25 NFL Draft
For additional coverage of University of Michigan athletics:
- Subscribe to our YouTube channel: @WingedHelmetMedia
- Follow us on Facebook: @TheWingedHelmet
- Follow us on Twitter: @TWH_chris | @TrentKnoop | @mlounsberry_SI | @JerredJohnson7