New NIL Scandal: UNLV QB Drama Highlights College Sports' Broken Promises

Jan 1, 2025

Former UNLV QB Matthew Sluka / Jay Biggerstaff-Imagn Images

In this story:

The ongoing debate surrounding NIL (Name, Image, and Likeness) agreements took another turn this season, and UNLV found itself at the center of the conversation. While headlines have been dominated by news of six former Florida State basketball players suing their head coach over unfulfilled NIL promises, the Rebels faced a similar controversy involving quarterback Matthew Sluka earlier this year.

The latest NIL controversy involving Florida State broke Monday when six former basketball players filed a lawsuit against head coach Leonard Hamilton. The players allege that Hamilton promised each of them $250,000 in NIL payments that they never received. This lawsuit has amplified ongoing concerns about the lack of enforceability and transparency in NIL agreements across collegiate athletics.

Florida State Head Coach, Leonard Hamilton, is being sued by 6 former players over an alleged 1.5 million dollars in owed NIL compensation from last season according to multiple sources pic.twitter.com/166JKSYy3x
— Hoop Herald (@TheHoopHerald) December 30, 2024

Sluka, a high-profile transfer from Holy Cross, joined UNLV with expectations of a significant NIL payout. Sluka claims he was promised $100,000 as part of his agreement to transfer to the Rebels. However, after starting the first three games of the season, Sluka departed the program, citing that the NIL payments he was assured never materialized. He completed 21 of 48 passes for 318 yards, six touchdowns, and one interception. He also tallied 253 rushing yards on 39 carries with one additional trip to the end zone. Thanks to NCAA rules allowing players to redshirt after appearing in four or fewer games, Sluka preserved a year of eligibility and left UNLV with a cloud of uncertainty hanging over its program.

UNLV claimed that Sluka received everything he was promised and simply wanted more. UNLV also accused Sluka's agent of making “financial demands” that violated NCAA pay-for-play rules and Nevada state law.

The situation highlights a troubling trend in college athletics, where verbal agreements tied to NIL deals often lack enforcement mechanisms. While Sluka has not pursued legal action, his departure raises significant questions about the integrity of the NIL process and the responsibilities of programs to deliver on their promises.

Despite Sluka’s departure after the Rebels started the season 3-0, UNLV overcame the adversity and achieved a historic milestone. The team won its first bowl game since 2000, defeating the California Golden Bears 24-13. UNLV finished the season with an impressive 11-3 record, showcasing resilience and determination in a year filled with challenges.

Stay tuned for more updates on this story.

Recommended Articles