Chicago Bears' Caleb Williams Rookie Season A Bust Or Success? Coaching Search Chaos

Is Chicago Bears quarterback Caleb Williams' rookie season a bust or success? On film, there is much to critique and nitpick about the former No. 1 NFL Draft pick. The discourse is somewhere between the noise. Why is the young quarterback so polarizing and is the play on the field worth the fuss?

Dec 16, 2024; Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA; Chicago Bears quarterback Caleb Williams (18) talks to Minnesota Vikings head coach Kevin O'Connell after the game quarter at U.S. Bank Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Brad Rempel-Imagn Images / Brad Rempel-Imagn Images

Chicago Bears rookie quarterback Caleb Williams has always been a lightning rod for debate and opinion. Whether it be from his quirky fashion choices, painting his fingernails, or some of the quotes he’s made over the years that could be interpreted as poor in taste. What happens when those topics take over the general discourse, the most important thing to evaluate, the film that’s put on tape each week. 

There are good to great flashes throughout the tape and there are poor to terrible displays on the film. Caleb Williams’s rookie season will be one that will go down as one of the more contentious seasons in recent memory. Part of the disdain is due to the aforementioned quirks that Williams naturally presents. The other side has to do with the hype from media, analysts, and coaches in the pre-draft process. At the end of the day, the win-loss column is the biggest factor.

Caleb Williams has 8 TDs, 0 Ints, completing 65 percent of his passes for 1,014 yds in his last 5 games against 4 of the top coverage defenses in football.

all while being sacked 20 times during that stretch. Some people have got to relax.

trenches this off season. trenches

— Taylor Doll (@TayDoll1010xl) December 17, 2024

“Losing, it’s one of those things that actually really affects me. It’s tough. But I do have the understanding of where I’m at in my career and where I'll be at…So, having all that in mind, there’s a lot to be optimistic and positive about, because I’m not my best self yet, and that’s soon to come. I’m working towards that every day, and going to keep working towards that." said quarterback Caleb Williams in the mid-week presser. 

The Bears were a play away from being 5-2 before the Commanders Hail Mary conversion changed the course of their season. Then there was the meltdown against the Detroit Lions on Thanksgiving day. There was also the Vikings overtime loss in which Williams brought the Bears back from almost three scores down. There was also the one-point loss to the Green Bay Packers after a missed field goal as time expired.

MORE: USC Trojans, Lincoln Riley Biggest Transfer Portal Losers In College Football?

MORE: Chicago Bears' Caleb Williams Injury Update After Franchise Record 58 Sacks

MORE: USC Trojans Program Falling Apart Under Lincoln Riley? Top Recruiting Classes Transferring

To add insult to injury, three of those matchups were in the NFC North division. How different would Williams’ season be viewed if the Bears had pulled those games out and are sitting at 7-7 with three division wins? Williams hasn’t been perfect and there’s obviously room for growth. Accuracy and footwork mainly, which are mainly intertwined. But, the constant sideshow is him, and the narratives that existed before he ever took a snap loom large.

.@olin_kreutz on Caleb Williams: "For people to say, 'He's fine, this does not affect him, the chaos in that building.' You got to be kidding me. His OC is gone, his head coach is gone.

"You never feel good when a coach gets fired. You feel like you had something to do with it." pic.twitter.com/7rNiFcZyYf

— 670 The Score (@670TheScore) December 17, 2024

 "For people to say, 'He's fine, this does not affect him, the chaos in that building.' You got to be kidding me. His offensive coordinator is gone, his head coach is gone. We saw during Hardknocks him meeting with coach Eberflus. All of sudden he gets fired. As a player you never feel good when a coach gets fired. You feel like you had something to do with it." said Bears legend Olin Kreutz about Williams’s surroundings. 

Change has been the only consistent part of Caleb Williams’ rookie season. It’s what to expect on some level, but going through multiple head coaches and three offensive coordinators in one season is unprecedented. Add in the injuries to the offensive line and other key positions, it can be difficult to keep your head above water, especially if you’re experiencing self doubt along the way.

The head coaching search continues for Chicago and hot names rumored for the job are Ben Johnson, Kliff Kingsbury, Mike Vrabel and Joe Brady.

pic.twitter.com/P4GIzHkIjQ

— I🧸 (@ilannfl) December 17, 2024

"You motivate yourself, you encourage yourself. You have positive affirmations that you say to yourself. With that, it makes the days better, it makes when you’re going through a tough patch, it makes those days a little bit easier rather than pulling yourself down, telling yourself you’re this and that. ... I tell myself certain things: ‘I am great. I will be great.’ All these different things. So, I think that’s one of the biggest things, is not pulling yourself down and being gracious with yourself,” Williams continued. 

Williams has already had the best rookie season in Bears franchise history: 2,937 passing yards, 17 passing touchdowns, 62 percent completion, five interceptions, and 408 rushing yards is very respectable at face value. What’s been used as a negative in the daily discussion should actually be the most encouraging part, that there’s so much room to get better. 

MORE: USC Trojans' Elijah Hughes Enters Transfer Portal: 18 Outgoing USC Transfers

MORE: Georgia Bulldogs, Florida Gators Targeting Transfer Portal Receiver Zachariah Branch

MORE: Ohio State Buckeyes to Land Transfer Portal Running Back Quinten Joyner From USC?

MORE: USC Trojans Football Schedule: Grueling Road Opponents, Intriguing Home Slate In 2025