Peyton Manning and Eli Manning Had the Most Boring Reactions to Jets’ Walk-Off TD

Peyton Manning and Eli Manning Had the Most Boring Reactions to Jets’ Walk-Off TD Against Bills.

The New York Jets beat the Buffalo Bills in thrilling fashion Monday with a 65-yard walk-off punt return in overtime by undrafted rookie Xavier Gipson that sent MetLife Stadium into hysterics. 

You know who didn’t seem all that thrilled by that incredible ending? Peyton Manning and Eli Manning, who were doing the season’s first ManningCast on ESPN2. 

It was a long night of football, with the biggest story happening just four snaps into the game when Aaron Rodgers left with an ankle injury that might be very serious. So maybe the Manning brothers were a bit tired, because this didn’t have any type of energy at all: 

The ManningCast is left STUNNED by that Xavier Gipson punt return touchdown!! pic.twitter.com/vT4UKPVRyV

— Awful Announcing (@awfulannouncing) September 12, 2023

Their reaction earlier in the game to Rodgers’ injury was much better than that. 

Fans had blasted their boring call of the winning TD: 

Were they all asleep? That was the most boring call I’ve ever heard. https://t.co/9SOlxPS6Du

— Stef Fanski (@Oh__Cleveland) September 12, 2023

i normally am a fan of the manningcast but every clip i’ve seen has just been them being heartbroken over every good thing the jets have done https://t.co/avoIFyM5uN

— nick (sports hater) (@NickOnTV_) September 12, 2023

why did they just… not react? https://t.co/GN8GegcZQX

— drake c. toll, party animal. (@drakectoll) September 12, 2023

If you have less energy than Joe Buck, just retire. https://t.co/HMoHXTg46G

— Grant Lefelar (@GrantRLefelar) September 12, 2023

I'm glad I didn't watch the Manningcast tonight because it sounds like Peyton and Eli were reallyyyyy bummed the Jets won https://t.co/XCK54BMT94

— Adam Zielonka (@Adam_Zielonka) September 12, 2023

Shouldn’t they have feigned more excitement https://t.co/NlyejrSLPk

— John 🐶🏀 (@UrbyJT) September 12, 2023