McDonald's All-American Game snubs: 10 who should have made the 2024 boys team

East and West rosters were revealed Tuesday for the biggest all-star high school basketball game of the year

Cooper Flagg was a slam dunk to make the 2024 McDonald's All-American Game roster, but mercy, there were some big-time snubs — including two of his Montverde Academy teammates.

The boys East and West teams for the 2024 McDonald's All-American Game on April 2 were announced Tuesday, and and now we'll shine the spotlight on some players who should have made the cut.

Vote: Who was most deserving of making the 2024 boys McDonald's All-American Game?

To make SBLive Sports' list of the top 10 snubs, players had to have been nominated for the game.

Annor Boateng, Little Rock Central (Arkansas)

The Central Tigers defeated North Little Rock 55-49 on January 3, 2023 in an Arkansas boys basketball Class 6A central conference matchup.
Annor Boateng jams one over a North Little Rock defender / Photo by Braeden Botts

6-foot-6, 210-pound F, Missouri Tigers signee

The defending Gatorade Arkansas Player of the Year has been even better as a senior, averaging a double-double while leading Little Rock Central to an 18-4 start and No. 3 ranking in the state.

Morez Johnson, Thornton (Illinois)

Morez Johnson played for St. Rita last season before transferring to Thornton.
Morez Johnson played for St. Rita last season before transferring to Thornton / Photo by Nate Latsch

6-foot-9, 235-pound C, Illinois Fighting Illini signee

Johnson has been racking up double-doubles for No. 3-ranked Thornton after transferring from St. Rita. He recently scored a career-high 30 points, adding 17 rebounds and six blocked shots in a win over Niles North.

Kon Knueppel, Wisconsin Lutheran (Wisconsin)

6-foot-5, 205-pound F, Duke Blue Devils signee

Knueppel seemed to be a lock to make the team after stringing together 30-point games this season, including a 38-point symphony to help end De Pere's 42-game win streak.

Jackson McAndrew, Wayzata (Minnesota)

Jackson McAndrew is one of the fastest-rising senior recruits in the country.
Jackson McAndrew is one of the fastest-rising senior recruits in the country / Photo by Earl Ebensteiner

6-foot-9, 210-pound F, Creighton Bluejays signee

McAndrew flew up the recruiting rankings off a stellar junior season in which he led Wayzata to a state title. He's kept the momentum going as a senior, averaging over 20 points per game.

Mercy Miller, Sherman Oaks Notre Dame (California)

Notre Dame/Sherman Oaks senior guard Mercy Miller.
Sherman Oaks Notre Dame senior guard Mercy Miller is averaging 30.5 points per game :: Tarek Fattal/SBLive

6-foot-4, 180-pound G, Houston Cougars signee

Miller, who scored 68 points in a game earlier this season against Oakwood, is averaging 30.5 points, 10 rebounds and 4.5 assists per game this season for the 23-0 Notre Dame Knights. The son of rapper Master P recently had 29 points and 11 rebounds in a win over Harvard-Westlake.

Asa Newell, Montverde Academy (Florida)

Asa Newell is the highest-ranked recruit to not make the McDonald's All-American roster.
Asa Newell is the highest-ranked recruit to not make the McDonald's All-American roster / Photo by Matt Christopher

6-foot-9, 205-pound F, Georgia Bulldogs signee

Newell is the highest-ranked recruit to not make the McDonald's All-American Game, and it has to do with the team he plays for. Only three players are allowed on the roster from one team, and Cooper Flagg, Derik Queen and Liam McNeeley are the three who made it from national No. 1 Montverde Academy. We'll let readers debate whether it's a fair rule, but Newell surely doesn't like it at all. He'd be a shoo-in without it.

Ahmad Nowell, Imhotep Charter (Pennsylvania)

Ahmad Nowell (0) is averaging over 25 points per game this season.
Ahmad Nowell (0) is averaging over 25 points per game this season / Photo by Nate Latsch

6-foot, 180-pound G, UConn Huskies signee

Nowell showed his all-around game in the Panthers' 58-41 win against DeMatha Catholic (Maryland) at the Hoophall Classic, finishing with 17 points, five rebounds, nine assists, and three steals. He's averaging over 25 points per game this season.

Jase Richardson, Columbus (Florida)

Jase Richardson (4) led Columbus to the Les Schwab Invitational championship.
Jase Richardson (4) led Columbus to the Les Schwab Invitational championship / Photo by Naji Saker

6-foot-3, 180-pound G, Michigan State Spartans signee

Richardson led the Explorers with 19 points, six rebounds and two blocks in the Les Schwab Invitational championship game win over Harvard-Westlake (California). He's been the senior leader on a team that features the Boozer twins.

Billy Richmond, Camden (New Jersey)

6-foot-5, 200-pound G, Kentucky Wildcats commit

Richmond, a Tennessee native, keeps rising the recruiting rankings and is now in 247Sports' top 20 in the Class of 2024. He's averaging nearly 20 points a game this season and popped a heck of a buzzer beater earlier this month.

Robert Wright, Montverde Academy (Florida)

Robert Wright runs the point for superstar-laden Montverde Academy.
Robert Wright runs the point for superstar-laden Montverde Academy / Photo by Matt Christopher

6-foot, 165-pound G, Baylor Bears signee

See the Asa Newell write-up. Same deal, different superstar player for a superstar-stocked team.

-- Mike Swanson | swanson@scorebooklive.com | @sblivesports


Published
Mike Swanson, SBLive Sports
MIKE SWANSON

Mike Swanson is the VP of Content for High School On SI. He's been in journalism since 2003, having worked as a reporter, city editor, copy editor and high school sports editor in California, Connecticut and Oregon.