Signing Joe Nathan is a start to repairing the woeful Tigers bullpen

The Tigers should benefit from signing a consistent closer in Joe Nathan. (Paul Sancya/AP) The Tigers’ trade of Prince Fielder for Ian Kinsler freed
Signing Joe Nathan is a start to repairing the woeful Tigers bullpen
Signing Joe Nathan is a start to repairing the woeful Tigers bullpen /

The Tigers should benefit from signing a consistent closer in Joe Nathan. (Paul Sancya/AP)

The Tigers should benefit from signing a consistent closer in Joe Nathan. (Paul Sancya/AP)

The Tigers’ trade of Prince Fielder for Ian Kinsler freed considerable future payroll but did mean giving up the better player. Detroit’s shipment of starter Doug Fister to the Nationals for a package of three players was viewed skeptically, though general manager David Dombrowski should have the benefit of the doubt given his excellent track record in trades. With that said, trading Fister appeared more like a salary dump than an equal exchange of player value, which is a curious move for a contender.

The unambiguously positive move, however, was the signing of free-agent closer Joe Nathan, a moved formally announced on Wednesday. For two straight Octobers, Detroit has been plagued by a porous bullpen with too few dependable late-inning relievers. They ranked 24th in the majors during the regular season with a 4.01 bullpen ERA.

The back of the Tigers’ bullpen was a revolving door last year. Phil Coke, Jose Valverde and Bruce Rondon all failed to fill the ninth-inning void before Joaquin Benoit exceled in the job -- but only during the regular season. Though he had a 2.01 ERA through September, Benoit allowed four runs in 5 2/3 innings of October work and now is a free agent anyway.

Nathan, though he turned 39 last month, is coming off one of his finest seasons as a major leaguer. He had 43 saves, a 1.39 ERA and 0.90 WHIP as the Rangers’ closer; all three of those figures were top-10 in the majors among pitchers with at least 60 innings. Nathan is clearly well past his Tommy John surgery that cost him all of 2010 and led to a poor 2011, before he rebounded nicely in ’12 and ’13.

The Tigers still need to add at least one and ideally two or three more impact arms for the bullpen, but Nathan is an excellent start to repairing the unit that has lost Benoit to free agency and could lose Drew Smyly to the rotation. The reported terms of the deal are two years for about $10 million per season, with an option for a third year, and while some regression is expected -- even Craig Kimbrel can’t be expected to sustain a 1.39 ERA at any age, much less at 40 like Nathan -- he should provide plenty of value to Detroit.


Published
Joe Lemire
JOE LEMIRE

Staff Writer, Sports Illustrated Staff writer Joe Lemire is in his seventh year at Sports Illustrated and his fourth season covering baseball full time. Lemire writes features and analysis for SI and SI.com and is responsible for the website's weekly MLB Power Rankings. He has profiled Pirates star Andrew McCutchen and Braves rookie sensation Evan Gattis for the magazine. Lemire's penchant for covering America's pastime is to be expected considering his inspirations, Tom Verducci and Peter Gammons, are among the most well-known writers in the sport. Before his current role, Lemire spent his first three years with SI oscillating between baseball, college basketball, high school football and sports business. This came on the heels of a summer internship with the magazine in 2004 and a tenure as a stringer with SI: On Campus. Born in Richmond, Va., and raised in Lowell, Mass., Lemire graduated from the University of Virginia in 2005 with a B.A. in government and a minor in economics. Before joining SI he covered high school and college sports for the Daily News-Record in Harrisonburg, Va. He earned two Virginia Press Association awards for his work, one while a student writing at University of Virginia's Cavalier Daily and one at the Daily News-Record.