SF Giants: Farhan Zaidi and Greg Johnson backtrack Gabe Kapler's job security

The SF Giants had publicly committed to Gabe Kapler as manager in 2024, but Greg Johnson and Farhan Zaidi seemingly backtracked this week.
SF Giants: Farhan Zaidi and Greg Johnson backtrack Gabe Kapler's job security
SF Giants: Farhan Zaidi and Greg Johnson backtrack Gabe Kapler's job security /
In this story:

The SF Giants may have still been competing for a playoff spot, but last month, chairman Greg Johnson committed to manager Gabe Kapler and president of baseball operations Farhan Zaidi returning to the team next season. However, a lot has changed since then. The Giants were in the driver's seat for the final National League Wild Card but have since fallen completely out of the race. In danger of finishing below-.500, worse than they did last season, it seems like Kapler's future with the organization may actually be in jeopardy.

SF Giants president of baseball operations Farhan Zaidi talks to reporters. (2021)
SF Giants president of baseball operations Farhan Zaidi talks to reporters. (2021) / Sergio Estrada-USA TODAY Sports

“I really appreciate the support from ownership and the plan to have both of us back,” Zaidi said during an appearance on "Tolbert & Copes" on KNBR on Thursday. “Right now, our focus is just kind of getting through these last three games strong, finishing at .500. I think we all have to just look at how we can improve across the board. That's the personnel on the roster. That's, you know, our culture in the clubhouse, which again, I think that's when you're playing well, certain things culturally are portrayed positively like, 'Hey, this group loves being together. They're having fun.' But when you're not doing well, those things can be seen in a negative light."

While the start of Zaidi's answer did not signal any change was imminent, as he continued, it seemed to raise a lot of questions about the manager.

"And I just think we have to look at everything," Zaidi continued. "There's a time and place for everything. One hundred sixty-two games is a grind. We want our players to be comfortable being able to wash off those tough losses. But when you’re in do-or-die games, like we were in Arizona, you want them to feel different. I think we’re really gonna have to ask ourselves if we were prepared to sort of elevate our level of focus in play for those games that really matter down the stretch.”

Zaidi could have been talking about a broader culture shift, something some people argued ace Logan Webb hinted at last week. However, the fact that he focused on saying the team did not feel the way he wanted when they were in Arizona suggests something a bit higher on the chain of command. Something like a failure from the managerial position.

Susan Slusser of The San Francisco Chronicle reached out to Johnson on Friday, asking him about Zaidi's comments. Rather than taking the opportunity to say Zaidi was not making any broader hints, he simply told Slusser that he “stands by the comments Farhan made on KNBR.” It sure seems like the top executives with the SF Giants are signaling that Gabe Kapler's future with the organization is at least more uncertain than it was a month ago.


Published
Marc Delucchi
MARC DELUCCHI

Marc Delucchi (he/they/she) serves as the Managing Editor at Giants Baseball Insider, leading their SF Giants coverage. As a freelance journalist, he has previously covered the San Francisco Giants at Around the Foghorn and McCovey Chronicles. He also currently contributes to Niners Nation, Golden State of Mind, and Baseball Prospectus. He has previously been featured in several other publications, including SFGate, ProFootballRumors, Niners Wire, GrandStand Central, Call to the Pen, and Just Baseball. Over his journalistic career, Marc has conducted investigations into how one prep baseball player lost a college opportunity during the pandemic (Baseball Prospectus) and the rampant mistreatment of players at the University of Hawaii football program under former head coach Todd Graham (SFGate). He has also broken dozens of news stories around professional baseball, primarily around the SF Giants organization, including the draft signing of Kyle Harrison, injuries and promotions to top prospects like Heliot Ramos, and trade details in the Kris Bryant deal. Marc received a Bachelor's degree from Kenyon College with a major in economics and a minor in Spanish. During his time in college, he conducted a summer research project attempting to predict the future minor-league performance of NCAA hitters, worked as a data analyst for the school's Women's basketball team, and worked as a play-by-play announcer/color commentator for the basketball, baseball, softball, and soccer teams. He also worked as an amateur baseball scout with the Collegiate Baseball Scouting Network (later renamed Evolution Metrix), scouting high school and college players for three draft cycles. For tips and inquiries, feel free to reach out to Marc directly on Twitter or via email (delucchimarc@gmail.com).