Inside The Pinstripes

This Yankees Free Agent Has Unfinished Business in New York

Andrew Benintendi feels he didn't get to play his best baseball in the Bronx and is open to returning for next season.

Max Goodman

In this story:

Aaron Judge isn't the only Yankees outfielder entering free agency this offseason. 

There's another that doesn't feel fulfilled after a brief stretch in pinstripes. 

Andrew Benintendi, a rental acquired ahead of the trade deadline this summer, told Greg Joyce of the New York Post that he's open to returning to the Yankees this offseason. 

After an injury ended his season prematurely, holding him out for the postseason, Benintendi doesn't believe he was able to show Yankees fans what he's truly capable of.

"You get traded over and you want to help the team get far in the playoffs,” he said. “I started off slow. I don’t know, I just feel like I didn’t play my best baseball when I was here, healthy.”

There are no guarantees that Benintendi will be back, though. The veteran added that he will "listen to every team" this offseason. 

New York sent three pitching prospects to the Royals to grab Benintendi, one of the best left-handed hitters available at this year's deadline. Over 33 games with the Yankees, the left fielder slashed .254/.331/.404 with two home runs and 14 runs scored. Benintendi hit .320 with the Royals across 93 games before the trade, part of his seventh MLB season.

On September 2, Benintendi suffered a broken hook of his hamate bone. He was "close" to returning during the postseason, but ended up watching from the sidelines as his new team was eliminated by the Astros in the American League Championship Series. 

“Obviously I wanted to be out there and do what I could to help the team win,” Benintendi said. “But there’s only so much you can do. It just sucks that it didn’t heal in time.”

New York's outfield for next season is a huge question mark entering this offseason. There's a chance Judge doesn't return, leaving gargantuan shoes to fill in right field at Yankee Stadium. Even if he does re-sign and stick around for the foreseeable future, there's still an open spot in left field. 

Harrison Bader, another trade deadline acquisition, will start in center field with one year remaining on his current contract. As of now, either Aaron Hicks or infielder-turned-outfielder Oswaldo Cabrera would factor into the playing time equation in left.

Bringing Benintendi back for another season would provide this lineup with a consistent contact-first bat, a player capable of leading off or providing some pop to the middle and bottom of the order. That's something New York was missing during the playoffs—the Yankees managed just 21 hits, a .501 OPS and nine total runs in the ALCS, a four-game sweep.

Benintendi plays quality defense as well. The 28-year-old won a Gold Glove Award in left field last season. He's a finalist for that same award again in 2022. 

MORE:

Follow Max Goodman on Twitter (@MaxTGoodman), be sure to bookmark Inside The Pinstripes and check back daily for news, analysis and more.

Published
Max Goodman
MAX GOODMAN

Max Goodman covers the New York Yankees for Sports Illustrated and FanNation. Goodman has been on the Yankees beat for three seasons. He is also the publisher of Sports Illustrated and FanNation's Jets site, Jets Country. Before starting Inside The Pinstripes, Goodman attended Northwestern University and the Medill School of Journalism. He earned his Bachelor’s Degree in Broadcast Journalism and Master’s Degree in Sports Media, graduating in 2019. At school, Goodman was an anchor and reporter with NNN SportsNight and played on the club baseball team. While at Northwestern, Goodman interned with MLB.com as an associate reporter covering the Miami Marlins. He also interned with ESPN, working as an associate reporter on Mike Greenberg's Get Up. Goodman is from New York City. He grew up in Hell's Kitchen. Follow Goodman on Twitter @MaxTGoodman. You can connect with him via email by reaching out at maxgoodmansports@gmail.com.

Home/News