SI:AM | Tyrese Maxey Has His Superstar Moment

He saved the Sixers’ season with two of the best clutch shots you’ll ever see.

Maxey (0) willed Philly to a Game 5 overtime win Tuesday. / Brad Penner-USA TODAY Sports

Good morning, I’m Dan Gartland. The beekeeper who saved the day in Phoenix is my new hero.

In today’s SI:AM:

🔥 Maxey takes over
☘️ C’s announcer says goodbye
🐎 The 150th Kentucky Derby

He made the Garden fall silent

The NBA postseason is when players forge their legacies—and Philadelphia 76ers guard Tyrese Maxey just solidified his status as a true star with a legacy-defining Game 5 against the New York Knicks.

Maxey thrived during the regular season after being thrust into a bigger role by the departure of James Harden and Joel Embiid’s injury in late January. He averaged a career-best 25.9 points per game—11th in the NBA—and was rewarded by being named the league’s Most Improved Player last week.

With Embiid clearly hobbled by his troublesome left knee, the Sixers needed Maxey to save the day as they faced elimination in Game 5 at Madison Square Garden—and he absolutely did. Maxey hit two of the most clutch shots you’ll ever see in the final 30 seconds of the fourth quarter to send the game to overtime.

The Knicks appeared to have the game wrapped up after Jalen Brunson passed out of a double team to a wide-open Miles McBride, who knocked down a jumper at the foul line to extend the New York lead to six with 28.9 seconds on the clock. But then Maxey took over, and, thanks in part to a couple of errors by the Knicks, saved his team’s season.

First Maxey used a pump fake to get Knicks center Mitchell Robinson to leave his feet and leaned into Robinson to draw the foul as he threw up an off-balance three-point attempt. He got the shot to fall and then hit the ensuing free throw for a four-point play to cut the deficit to two. Then, after Josh Hart missed one of two free throws to leave the door open for a comeback, Maxey buried the shot of the playoffs thus far: a leaning 35-footer to tie the game at 97.

MAXEY DELIVERS IN THE CLUTCH 😱

WE'RE HEADING TO OT! pic.twitter.com/SCI4aNRPMY

— NBA on TNT (@NBAonTNT) May 1, 2024

On the Knicks’ home broadcast on MSG Network, play-by-play announcer Mike Breen repeatedly stressed before Philadelphia’s final possession how New York couldn’t allow a three-point attempt and needed to foul the Sixers. But Embiid’s screen near the halfcourt line gave Maxey plenty of space and his decision to shoot it from so far out meant Robinson wasn’t remotely close enough to give the foul.

Maxey’s heroics defined the fourth quarter, but the story of the overtime period was just the Knicks blowing it. They jumped out to a quick five-point lead before the Sixers responded with a 9–0 run. The Knicks managed to tie the game again at 106 but the Sixers scored the final six points of the game to win it. Any chance of a Knicks victory was essentially wiped out when, after New York forced a sloppy Sixers turnover with Philadelphia leading 108–106 with 28 seconds to play, Jalen Brunson turned it right back over with an ill-advised pass.

Maxey finished with 46 points, a playoff career high and the fourth-highest total of his career. He’s averaging 32.4 points, 7.2 assists and 5.2 rebounds per game during the series.

The Sixers will need Maxey to step up again as the series shifts back to Philadelphia for Game 6 on Thursday night. Embiid has had his moments during the series—including a 50-point outburst in Game 3—but his knee was clearly bothering him more in Game 5 than it had previously. He made plenty of great plays, but his mobility was severely lacking. He finished with 19 points on 7-of-19 shooting, 16 rebounds, 10 assists and a staggering nine turnovers, which tied a career worst.

If Embiid’s knee isn’t any better on Thursday, the pressure will be on Maxey to be the hero again and force a Game 7 back in New York. After willing his team to victory on Tuesday, everyone knows he’s capable of that.

New England begins a new era with first-round pick Drake Maye at quarterback. / Eric Canha-USA TODAY Sports

The best of Sports Illustrated

• Chris Mannix spoke with longtime Celtics announcer Mike Gorman, who is retiring after 43 years behind the microphone.

• Matt Verderame has a list of five AFC draft picks who are most likely to be busts.

• Conor Orr has new NFL power rankings that take into account the results of last week’s draft.

• Ahead of the 150th running of the Kentucky Derby this weekend, Pat Forde looks back on the history of the iconic race.

• Terrible news for AL home run leader Mike Trout, who will miss significant time after undergoing knee surgery. Trout was on the verge of tears when discussing the injury.

• Celtics big man Kristaps Porziņģis will reportedly miss multiple games due to his calf injury.

• Knicks forward Bojan Bogdanović will miss the rest of the playoffs after undergoing season-ending surgery.

The top five…

… things I saw last night: 

5. The bench-clearing brawl between the Brewers and Rays.
4. Evgeny Kuznetsov’s bizarre penalty shot against the Islanders.
3. Maple Leafs goalie Joseph Woll’s pad save to keep the game tied in the third period. 
2. Matthew Knies’s overtime goal to win the game for Toronto and force a Game 6.
1. The beekeeper who rose to the occasion and ended a two-hour delay in the Diamondbacks game. He even got to throw out the first pitch.