Magic Overwhelmed by Knicks, but Advance in NBA Cup as Wild Card

The Orlando Magic were no match for the New York Knicks, one of their chief competitors in the Eastern Conference. But because of their plus-45 point differential after four games, the Magic advanced to the next round in the NBA Cup tournament.

New York Knicks guard Cameron Payne (1) knocks the ball away from Orlando Magic guard Anthony Black (0) during the first quarter at Madison Square Garden. / Brad Penner-Imagn Images

NEW YORK — Tuesday night in Madison Square Garden, with a national TV audience watching, the Orlando Magic punched first.

Their first three triples of the night dropped and, after barely more than four minutes, the Magic led this Eastern Conference showdown 14-6.

To keep pace with the New York Knicks offense, a unit that Magic coach Jamahl Mosley called "high-paced," his players would have to convert these good looks and Orlando's third-ranked defense would have to make a stand.

But the Knicks wouldn't cooperate. They lit up the Magic for 71 first-half points, led by 31 after three quarters, and coasted to a 121-106 victory.

"I think we didn't have our usual effort and physicality on defense," Franz Wagner said postgame. "They got into a rhythm and we really didn't at any point in the game offensively."

New York closed out NBA Cup group play 4-0 and advanced to the knockout round of the in-season tournament. Orlando, 3-1, also advanced by virtue of a plus-45 point differential that the Magic preserved by playing starters Wagner and Jalen Suggs for most of the lopsided fourth quarter.

Postgame, both Mosley and Wagner confirmed that they were aware of the NBA Cup implications and what was required to advance to the tournament's next stage.

"I mean, at some point when you're down 30, I think you've gotta start talking about [it]," Wagner said. "Obviously, you want to play every minute regardless of what the score is, but I think that should definitely add motivation to not let your head hang and just continue to fight."

With a 31-15 final period, the Magic earned the East's wild-card spot in the NBA Cup knockout round. They will play the Bucks in Milwaukee either Dec. 10 or 11.

"We earned our way to the quarterfinal," Wagner said. "Obviously not our best game today, but that's why you play every minute in the other games. It feels weird even after a game like this to advance, but yeah, that's just part of it."

New York scored at least 35 points in the game's first three quarters. Karl-Anthony Towns' 23 points led a group of six Knicks in double figures.

The Knicks shot 50.6 percent from the field, made 15 threes, then added 20 more points on a perfect night at the free-throw line.

These games against the NBA's contenders are all that much tougher for the Magic with All-Star Paolo Banchero watching from the bench.

"You don't make up for what Paolo does," Mosley said. "I think you just have to adjust to find the right things to do within the group of young men who are also hungry to step into a different role."

After 12 wins in 13 games, the Magic blew a tire. They lacked offensive firepower beyond Franz Wagner, who scored 30 points for the sixth time this season. Moe Wagner (20), Jalen Suggs (14), and Cole Anthony (10) eventually reached double digits, but it was far too late in the evening to matter.

"Listen, give New York a ton of credit for how they played. They played hard, they played physical, they played the right way in so many ways," Mosley said. "But ultimately, also, this wasn't Orlando Magic-style basketball. It was a stinker. We'll sit with that, then we'll move on and we've got to take care of Philly tomorrow."

New York scored 32 points off Magic turnovers and Orlando trailed by as much as 37 in the second half.

Shortly before tipoff, Orlando learned it would be without starting center Goga Bitadze. He was a late scratch with a right ankle sprain. Rookie wing Tristan da Silva started in his place.

Mosley said postgame that Bitadze suffered the injury during his pregame shooting slot. His status will be one to monitor over the remainder of the team's road trip.

Up Next

The Magic continue their five-game road trip with the second leg of a back-to-back Wednesday night in Philadelphia against the 76ers. Tipoff is 7:30 p.m at the Wells Fargo Center.

Related Stories on the Orlando Magic

• ESPN'S 25 UNDER 25 FEATURES 3 MAGIC: The Orlando Magic have three players on ESPN's NBA '25 under 25' list CLICK HERE
• PAOLO'S STARDOM GROWS GIVING BACK IN NYC: Banchero spent his Monday afternoon surprising kids from the Boys and Girls Club of Harlem with a shopping spree at the NBA Store in New York. CLICK HERE
• MAGIC'S RELIANCE ON POISE AND MATURITY: Orlando has superpowers, ones they've garnered through years of trudging through results to end up where they are now: maturity and poise. CLICK HERE
• PAOLO BANCHERO BACK ON THE COURT: The All-Star forward is making progress toward a return for the first time since tearing his oblique Oct. 30. CLICK HERE
• 3 THINGS MAGIC ARE THANKFUL FOR: Wrecking-ball defense, another star and being unbeatable at home – there's plenty to be thankful for with the Magic this year. CLICK HERE
• MAGIC GIVE BACK THIS THANKSGIVING: See how the Magic organization gave back to Central Florida's less fortunate this holiday. CLICK HERE
• FRANZ HAS 'GOTTA BE' AN ALL-STAR, SHAMS SAYS: Orlando Magic forward Franz Wagner has been turning heads and forcing people to take notice of his recent performances. Now, ESPN's Shams Charania says he should be an All-Star lock. CLICK HERE
• MAGIC'S 2024-25 SCHEDULE: See the complete slate for the Orlando Magic in 2024-25 and all the details – dates, locations, TV, tip times, and more – that you need to know. CLICK HERE

Want more Orlando Magic coverage on Sports Illustrated?

Follow 'Orlando Magic on SI' on Facebook and like our page. Follow Magic beat reporter Mason Williams on Twitter/X @mvsonwilliams. Also, bookmark our homepage so you never miss a story.