Mark Schlereth Explains Why J.J. McCarthy May Be More Pro-Ready Than Other QBs in Draft

The Wolverines quarterback has been a fast riser this draft season.

J.J. McCarthy is a popular name during NFL draft season this year, as the Michigan quarterback has climbed up boards to become a possible top 10 pick. While many fans are left wondering what NFL teams are seeing in McCarthy compared to other top quarterbacks in the draft, one analyst believes that McCarthy has one attribute that gives him an advantage over the rest.

Mark Schlereth explained on the Stinkin’ Truth Podcast that McCarthy’s experience in Michigan’s pro-style system means he is more ready to enter the NFL than other quarterback prospects.

“He’s one-of-one as far as I’m concerned when it comes to quarterbacks who operate at the line of scrimmage in a pro-style system,” Schlereth said. “He’s in control at the line of scrimmage. He’s not just looking at a card saying ‘barn, rooster, chicken,’ he’s actually operating and changing strength calls.”

Why JJ McCarthy is shooting up draft boards. The stinking trip Podcast...https://t.co/IG3WDRPqoX pic.twitter.com/tdcES3ojbX

— Mark Schlereth (@markschlereth) March 9, 2024

McCarthy was coached by Jim Harbaugh for three years, and Harbaugh’s experience as an NFL coach likely benefited McCarthy’s development. In two seasons as a starter, McCarthy threw for 44 touchdowns to just nine interceptions, although his production was more inconsistent than other top quarterbacks.

Schlereth added that he was taught how a quarterback’s college production isn’t as important for scouting as displaying NFL traits. While top prospects like Caleb Williams, Drake Maye and Jayden Daniels all thrived in college, their offensive systemes were different than McCarthy’s.

“When I look at these quarterbacks, I’m looking for transferable skill sets,” Schlereth. “That’s why I said J.J. McCarthy is shooting up the draft board because he’s the only guy who is operating pre-snap.”

NFL draft season always features at least one quarterback that impresses teams through the process, and McCarthy seems to be the choice this year.