Pro Football Focus names surprise choice for Bills best free agent signing of 2024

NFL free agency can be a roll of the dice. NFL general managers do their due diligence, watch the tape, talk to coaches and background checks but, the clock is ticking and they have to make a call. Bills general manager Brandon Beane knows this well and by all accounts has made some very good calls over his seven year tenure putting together the roster in Buffalo.
Last year saw the departure of Bills stalwarts Micah Hyde, Jordan Poyer, Gabe Davis and, of course, Stephon Diggs. Beane needed to find some talent -- particularly in the wide receiver room -- and he didn't waste any time. On back-to-back days in mid-March 2024, Beane signed Mack Hollins from the Falcons and Curtis Samuel from the Commanders. Given the contract details for both, the Bills got a steal -- Hollins.
So, given his onfield performance and off-field personality and unselfishness, it's not a surprise that Pro Football Focus named Mack Hollins their "Bills Best Free Agent of 2024".
Samuel was the splashier signing with a three year deal worth $28 million, while Beane signed Hollins to one year $2.6 million "prove it" contract. Hollins certainly did just that, turning in an excellent year in the Bills "everyone eats" offense. He went for 31 catches, 378 yards and a team-leading five touchdowns, including a huge one to keep them in the AFC championship game against the Chiefs.
JOSH ALLEN WITH DART TO MACK HOLLINS FOR THE SCORE π±
β Bleacher Report (@BleacherReport) January 27, 2025
WHAT A PLAY.
(via @NFL)
pic.twitter.com/b9ICJOjTpX
In addition, Hollins, with his unique personality and willingness to block as well as catch, has become a favorite both in the lockerroom and among the passionate Bills Mafia.
There canβt be one member of #BillsMafia that thought the signing of Mack Hollins this past offseason was going to result in such an absolute fan favorite. Dude fits this fanbase perfectly.. pic.twitter.com/nOdpxS3IRh
β Paul Tasker (@paulytasker) December 30, 2024
Mack Hollins arrives BAREFOOT in a WILD outfit.
β Dov Kleiman (@NFL_DovKleiman) December 22, 2024
πππpic.twitter.com/CsjirLRTav
The only mistake Brandon Beane made when he signed Hollins last year is that it was a one-year deal. Now Beane has to do it all over again - something the team and fans alike would say is a very good call.