NFL Fact or Fiction: The Eagles Are a Real Threat to the Lions

Philadelphia looks like a postseason contender, with a series of front office moves beginning to pay dividends. Plus, it may be time for the Jets to part ways with Aaron Rodgers.

Through 10 games, Barkley has scored 10 touchdowns and leads the NFL with 1,347 yards from scrimmage. / Bill Streicher-Imagn Images

The New York Jets are in the news again for firing GM Joe Douglas in a move that wasn’t surprising because of the team’s disappointing 3–8 record. 

With vacancies at GM and head coach, Aaron Rodgers could be forced to either retire or search for a new team. But maybe there’s a path in which Rodgers is back for a third season with the Jets. 

The Philadelphia Eagles don't have issues with their GM, but some had doubts about Howie Roseman after the team collapsed last season following a 10–1 start. During that disastrous finish, the defense quickly showed its age and the offense appeared broken with quarterback Jalen Hurts delivering mixed results. 

But as it turned out, Roseman was playing chess and we’re all finally seeing the moves he made to benefit the Eagles in the long run. Let’s discuss if the Eagles can compete with the mighty Detroit Lions and whether the Jets should welcome back Rodgers for this week’s Fact or Fiction. 

Eagles are a real threat to Lions thanks to Howie Roseman’s moves 

Manzano’s view: Fact 

We went nearly two months without football analysts constantly raving about how good Roseman is as the GM of the Eagles. Well, Roseman hasn’t lost his touch. It just took us a while to see the results on the field.

The draft picks from the past three years and the signing of running back Saquon Barkley have turned the Eagles into Super Bowl contenders again. They have the youth, experience, depth and star power to challenge the Lions when the NFC playoffs arrive in January.  

Order Now. SIP December Total Athlete. Get Sports Illustrated's Total Athlete issue. dark

It’s been impressive to see how Roseman fixed glaring roster holes from last season’s squad with draft picks from the past three years. He’s one of the best at what he does because he adds depth at various positions to have players prepared for when it’s their turn to play many snaps. Last season, linebacker Nakobe Dean and defensive tackle Jordan Davis didn’t appear ready to be starters, but they have improved in their third seasons. Like Dean and Davis, Cam Jurgens was drafted in 2022 and contributed at guard the past two seasons, but now he’s thriving as Jason Kelce’s replacement at center.

But the Eagles wouldn’t be 8–2 without the moves made this offseason. Philly’s secondary quickly went from old to potentially being set up for the next five years with rookies Quinyon Mitchell and Cooper DeJean. And veteran newcomer Zack Baun has improved a linebacker group that was among the worst in the league last season. 

Then there’s the signing of Barkley, who has rushed for 1,137 yards and eight touchdowns in his first 10 games with the Eagles. Philadelphia has the defense to throw off Lions quarterback Jared Goff and enough firepower to go toe-to-toe with Detroit in case they meet down the road.

Jets should welcome another Aaron Rodgers season 

Manzano’s view: Fiction

Now that the Jets’ 2024 season is essentially over, conversations have picked up about whether Rodgers, who turns 41 next month, will retire or return for a third season with the Jets. 

Perhaps the Jets shouldn’t give him a choice with Rodgers not being owed guaranteed money for the 2025 season. (The team would need to deal with $49 million in dead money if they were to cut Rodgers, according to OvertheCap.com.) It’s been two disastrous seasons with Rodgers. He has looked his age this year and only played four snaps in 2023 after tearing an Achilles. 

Also, committing to Rodgers would require his input for the general manager and head coach vacancies. And the team probably would have to figure out a way to rework Davante Adams’s outdated contract, which could be risky with a soon-to-be 32-year-old wide receiver. The new GM and coach probably want to construct the roster their way without having to add Rodgers’s former teammates in Green Bay. 

A third year with Rodgers could stunt the future of the Jets, but maybe there’s a world in which Rodgers doesn’t make roster demands and is content with being a bridge quarterback for a rookie signal-caller. But the Jets might be better off exploring the veteran market to pair with a young quarterback, just don’t expect a reunion with Sam Darnold, the former Jets QB who’s now thriving with the Minnesota Vikings. 

It’s tough to see Rodgers taking a backseat and not meddling with the Jets’ personnel decisions if he were to stick around in 2025. It’s time for a change because of what has occurred over the past two seasons.  

Jackson completed just 16 of 33 pass attempts against the Steelers, posting his lowest passer rating of the season (66.1). / Barry Reeger-Imagn Images

Someone other than Lamar Jackson will win MVP

Manzano’s view: Fact 

Many have argued that Joe Burrow shouldn’t be a candidate for MVP because the Cincinnati Bengals have a 4–7 record. But with that argument, we’re probably two plays away from Lamar Jackson not being an MVP candidate had the Ravens (7–4) lost the two close games against Burrow’s Bengals. 

Both Burrow and Jackson deserve MVP consideration, regardless of record. But you can also argue that those quarterbacks have benefited from playing with elite playmakers Ja’Marr Chase and Derrick Henry, respectively. For strange reasons, Chase, the Bengals’ star receiver, and Henry, the Ravens’ workhorse running back, won’t be strongly considered for MVP and will battle for Offensive Player of the Year.

But maybe Barkley has a strong chance of competing for the award that favors quarterbacks because Hurts hasn’t played as well as Burrow and Jackson. Barkley carried the team when the Eagles were without A.J. Brown and DeVonta Smith and has been the team’s best player throughout the season. You could also argue that Barkley’s signing is why the Eagles quickly returned to being Super Bowl contenders after a meltdown ending to the 2023 season. 

Barkley has a strong case, but again, he doesn’t play quarterback. Maybe this is the year Buffalo Bills quarterback Josh Allen breaks through. Allen had a signature moment when his 26-yard rushing touchdown helped the Bills beat the Kansas City Chiefs. Allen can help his case by delivering more MVP moments in upcoming high-profile games against the San Francisco 49ers and Lions.

It will be tough for Allen, Barkley, Burrow, and even Goff, to take the award from Jackson, but he shouldn’t be the strong favorite, not when the Ravens lost to the Las Vegas Raiders and Cleveland Browns. Also, Jackson won his two MVPs when the Ravens had the best record in the AFC. Baltimore might not win the AFC North this season because of the Pittsburgh Steelers (8–2), the team Jackson struggled against last week.  

Falcons will hold on to win NFC South

Manzano’s view: Fiction

The Atlanta Falcons have been too inconsistent to expect them to win the NFC South just because the three other teams in the division currently have losing records. 

The Falcons gave the other teams hope by ending the New Orleans Saints’ seven-game losing streak in Week 10 and getting crushed by 32 points against the Denver Broncos on Sunday. The Saints (4–7) are now two games behind the Falcons (6–5) for the division lead thanks to a two-game winning streak after firing coach Dennis Allen and replacing him with interim coach Darren Rizzi. 

But maybe the favorites in the division should be the Tampa Bay Buccaneers (4–6), losers of four consecutive games. Many thought their season was over after the Buccaneers lost wide receivers Chris Godwin and Mike Evans to significant injuries. But the Buccaneers were competitive vs. the Chiefs and 49ers before the bye week. Now, Baker Mayfield’s Bucs get the New York Giants, Carolina Panthers and Raiders the next three weeks. Don’t be surprised if Tampa Bay wins its fourth consecutive NFC South crown. 

Heck, maybe the Panthers (3–7) have a chance after winning back-to-back games against the Saints and Giants. 

The Falcons have two tough games against the Los Angeles Chargers and Vikings after their bye week. Atlanta needs to find consistency with Kirk Cousins and the offense. Also, surprisingly, coach Raheem Morris’s defense has struggled most of the season. The Falcons are allowing an average of 357.1 yards and 24.9 points per game.

The NFC South race is far from over after the Falcons gave the other divisional teams hope for the final two months of the season. 

Cowboys will free fall into the No. 1 pick in the 2025 draft

Manzano’s view: Fiction 

The Cowboys have played so poorly in their past two games that Jerry Jones is now being asked whether coach Mike McCarthy has lost the team. 

It does seem that way after blowout losses to the Eagles and Houston Texans, but the Cowboys have been a bad team all season and stand little to no chance of being competitive against playoff teams without Dak Prescott, who sustained a season-ending hamstring injury. 

The Cowboys (3–7) are still playing for McCarthy and that effort will probably show in games against the Giants (3–7) and Panthers (3–7) later this year. But winning those games won’t be easy because those two teams don’t seem interested in earning the No. 1 pick in next year’s draft. Giants coach Brian Daboll might be coaching for his job down the stretch, and the Panthers probably wouldn’t mind seeing quarterback Bryce Young produce a few more wins this season to give them hope for the future. 

There’s a strong chance the free-falling Cowboys will end up picking first for the upcoming draft, which not many saw coming for a team that won 12 games in each of the past three seasons. But that No. 1 pick probably belongs to one of the two-win teams in the AFC (Raiders, Browns, Tennessee Titans and Jacksonville Jaguars). I’m willing to bet at least one of those bad AFC teams won’t win a game again this season.   

---

More NFL on Sports Illustrated

feed