Falcons Need Kirk Cousins - But $180 Million Signing Leaves Questions

Quarterback questions have long dominated conversations surrounding the Atlanta Falcons. Kirk Cousins has been signed to be the answer - but still, questions remain.

The Atlanta Falcons - after years of having Lucy pull the ball away - have caught a big fish at the quarterback position.

Atlanta agreed to sign former Minnesota Vikings signal caller Kirk Cousins to a four-year contract Monday, bringing an end to the quarterback carousel that encapsulated former Falcons head coach Arthur Smith's final two seasons.

Cousins, a four-time Pro Bowler, brings Atlanta precisely what it wanted under center - a strong leader, an accurate passer and an established player capable of taking the organization back to the postseason.

The Falcons are in the midst of a six-year playoff drought. They've won 7 games five times in that spell, including each of the last three.

Falcons general manager Terry Fontenot and head coach Raheem Morris believed they were a quarterback away from contention - and decided to bet on Cousins.

It's an expensive bet, as Atlanta's giving Cousins a four-year, $180 million contract that includes $50 million to sign, $90 million fully guaranteed over the next two years, and $100 million guaranteed overall.

With an average annual value of $45 million, Cousins is tied with Kansas City Chiefs star Patrick Mahomes for the seventh-largest salary among NFL signal callers.

While steep, the Falcons had few other options.

Sep 10, 2023; Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA; Minnesota Vikings quarterback Kirk Cousins (8) throws a pass against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers during the first quarter at U.S. Bank Stadium / Credit: Jeffrey Becker-USA TODAY Sports

Last season, starting quarterbacks Desmond Ridder and Taylor Heinicke combined to complete 61.4 percent of their attempts for 3,726 yards, 17 touchdowns and 16 interceptions.

At the NFL Combine, Morris said he may not have his job had the Falcons received better quarterback play. He's not wrong - Atlanta went 7-10 in spite of its signal callers.

Cousins arrives in Flowery Branch surrounded by familiarity. The scheme he'll be playing in under offensive coordinator Zac Robinson should mirror that of Vikings head coach Kevin O'Connell, as both come from the Sean McVay school of offense.

As such, the concepts, ideas and terminology will be similar.

Further, Cousins already knows Morris, as the two were together with the now-Washington Commanders from 2012 to 2014. Morris was the team's defensive backs coach while Cousins was the backup signal caller.

Cousins' wife, Julie, is from Hampton, Georgia, and the couple has a home in the Atlanta area. Making the move won't be overly challenging.

On the field, Cousins gives the Falcons the best and most accomplished quarterback in the NFC South and is a substantial upgrade over Ridder and Heinicke.

Falcons owner Arthur Blank wants to win - the division, the conference, the Super Bowl. Cousins joins a roster ready-made to win, and he's expected to help Blank satisfy his dreams.

But is Cousins capable of elevating the Falcons above the San Francisco 49ers, Detroit Lions, Philadelphia Eagles or any other NFC contenders?

To date, Cousins hasn't proven consistently capable. In eight full years as a starter, his teams have finished either at or within a game of .500 on five occasions.

He went 7-9 in one year, 9-7 in another, and a pair of double-digit-win seasons with a 10-5 mark in 2019 and 13-4 record in 2022.

Beyond that, Cousins has struggled against good teams and under the playoff lights. He holds a career record of 14-43 when facing teams above .500 is only 1-3 as a starter in the postseason.

Consider further that Cousins, who turns 36 in August, is coming off a torn right Achilles suffered Oct. 29, and there are several questions surrounding his acquisition.

When the Falcons parted ways with Matt Ryan in March 2022, they did so because of cap space. Ryan was occupying nearly 25 percent of Atlanta's books, which Blank viewed as a direct prohibition to success.

"It had reached a point where, to remind everybody who may be aware of this or not, but in the last 20 years in the Super Bowl, there has never been a quarterback who’s been more than 17 percent of a team’s cap," Blank said Jan. 8. "We all signed up for it ... but at some point, you have to make a transition."

For Blank, Ryan's sizable contract derailed the Falcons from building a strong, deep roster.

"I think, unfortunately, it got us to a point where the salary cap situation was so burdensome that we couldn’t build the kind of franchise, the kind of roster that we needed to have going forward," Blank said. "It’s not a criticism of anybody. It’s just the reality of the National Football League."

Cousins' cap hit hasn't yet been revealed, but it likely will be less than the $45 million average annual value his deal suggests. If it were, with the NFL's $255 million salary cap, Cousins would make up 17.6 percent of Atlanta's money. It's more likely he's in the 10 to 14 percent range.

Still, Cousins isn't cheap - but he has the pedigree to unlock Atlanta's offense, which ranked No. 26 league-wide in scoring last season.

Tight end Kyle Pitts had 1,026 yards in his rookie season, when he caught passes from Ryan. Pitts has 1,023 receiving yards over 27 games in the past two years combined.

Pitts is merely one example of the young talent in the Falcons' weaponry, as receiver Drake London and running backs Bijan Robinson and Tyler Allgeier also factor into the equation.

Cousins' aerial success will not only direct impact Pitts and London as pass catchers but can lighten boxes for Robinson and Allgeier.

Last season, the Rams - where Robinson's offensive ideologies were developed - ran play action nearly 20 percent of the time, something Cousins is comfortable with. He's also proven well-suited in the clutch, leading 28 game-winning drives. He's led the league in the category twice in the past seven years.

And so, be it his late-game prowess, veteran leadership, consistent production or mere stability, Cousins is what the Falcons wanted - and needed - under center.

There's little doubt Atlanta's much better off with Cousins than without. Missing on the veteran passer meant either one of two things: trading up in the draft or making a move for Chicago Bears quarterback Justin Fields.

The draft route is uncertain. Each of the teams picking in the top three need quarterbacks, and the cost to move from No. 8 into No. 3 isn't cheap.

Further, the return of investment is much more boom-or-bust compared to the proven Cousins, and after years of uncertainty, one can hardly blame Fontenot for preferring the veteran avenue.

As for Fields, the Falcons did their homework, going as far as meeting with the Bears at the NFL Combine - but Fields was a secondary option.

Cousins checked the boxes the Falcons wanted. There are several others, at least from the outside, that are cause for concern.

There's a real chance Cousins brings Atlanta back to the playoffs, back to national relevancy and back to where the 81-year-old Blank needs to see his franchise.

Is Kirk Worth 'Mahomes Money'? Falcons QB Contract Details

But there's also the reality the Falcons continually come up short once they make the postseason and don't fully maximize their playoff window, which appears to be multiple years wide with several foundational players - both offensive and defensive - under contract for at least the next two years.

And yet, without Cousins, there may be no window - and Fontenot, Morris and Robinson now have a chance to fulfill Blank's greatest wish in 2024.