Can Falcons RB Tyler Allgeier Run His Way into Rookie of Year Race?

After a standout showing in the Atlanta Falcons' 21-18 loss to the New Orleans Saints, has rookie running back Tyler Allgeier vaulted himself into contention for the NFL's top offense rookie?

It's been just 14 weeks since Atlanta Falcons rookie running back Tyler Allgeier was a healthy scratch in the season opener, but it might as well have been forever ago.

Allgeier, a fifth-round pick in April's draft, has ascended to the top of Atlanta's running back's rotation, logging double digit carries in 10 of his 13 games ... culminating in a stellar 17-carry, 139-yard, one-touchdown performance in Sunday's 21-18 road loss to the New Orleans Saints.

It was Allgeier's first 100-yard rushing game - but far from his first impressive performance.

Despite entering the season behind veterans Cordarrelle Patterson and Damien Williams, Allgeier has spearheaded the NFL's third-ranked rushing attack, leading the Falcons in several categories, including carries (148), rushing yards (743), longest run (44 yards), first downs gained (36) and runs of 20 or more yards (five). The former BYU cougar is also Atlanta's only ballcarrier with at least 15 carries to not have a fumble to his name.

Over the final three games, Allgeier needs to average 85.7 rushing yards per game to hit 1,000 on the season, and 93.7 yards per game to surpass William Andrews' 1,023 yards from 1979, the current high mark among rookie running backs in franchise history.

But Allgeier's numbers stand up even outside of Atlanta. He ranks No. 20 league-wide in rushing yards, good for second among rookies, trailing only the Houston Texans' Dameon Pierce, and seventh among those who haven't all played 14 games.

Per NFL Next Gen Stats, Allgeier has totaled 136 rushing yards above expected, which leads the rookie class and ranks seventh in the league. His performance against the Saints netted a 76.5 percent success rate, the highest by any running back in any game this season, minimum 15 carries.

Considering when he was drafted and his Week 1 depth chart position, it's been an outstanding season for Allgeier - but has he done enough to warrant Offensive Rookie of the Year consideration?

The odds aren't in his favor, with FanDuel placing him at +6000 and PointsBet going as far as +10000, the 10th-best odds of any in the rookie class. New York Jets receiver Garrett Wilson is the heavy betting favorite, hauling in 67 passes for 966 yards and four touchdowns while dealing with quarterback inconsistencies.

But even if the odds aren't in Allgeier's favor, he remains extremely valuable to the Falcons in both the short- and long-term ... just ask coach Arthur Smith.

"We're happy we have Tyler," Smith said. "There's a lot of things he does that we value. For a rookie, something that's the hardest learning curve is the protection element, and he does a nice job of that. I do value the way he runs - you can see as the game goes on, his presence is felt."

Smith (sort of) compared the 5-11, 220-pound Allgeier to 5-10, 203-pound former Philadelphia Eagles All-Pro running back Brian Westbrook, who he coached against while serving as a defensive quality control coach for the Washington Commanders.

While stressing that they're "completely different runners," Smith sees a particular trait in Allgeier that helped Westbrook accumulate over 10,000 scrimmage yards during his nine-year professional career.

"The efficiency of him running the football, where you thought it was going to be a one-yard gain and you look up and it's 2nd and 5, those guys are valuable," said Smith. "They do it a completely different way, and the way Tyler does it, you guys have seen it - he's improved a lot and we're happy he's here."

And why wouldn't they be pleased to have Allgeier?

The 22-year-old is one of the most productive offensive rookies in football, leading a high-flying rushing attack while creating yards for himself better than any other first-year runner.

The end-of-season rookie honors may not go Allgeier's way - but his "value" and impact in Atlanta's offense goes well beyond any award and should only heighten in the years to come.


You can follow Daniel Flick on Twitter @DFlickDraft

Get your HOTlanta Falcons game tickets from SI Tickets ... here!

Want the latest in breaking news and insider information on the Falcons? Click Here.

Follow Falcon Report on Twitter.

Want even more Atlanta Falcons news? Check out the Si.com team page here


Published
Daniel Flick
DANIEL FLICK

Daniel Flick is an accredited NFL writer for Sports Illustrated's FanNation. Daniel has provided boots-on-ground coverage at the NFL Combine and from the Atlanta Falcons' headquarters, among other destinations, and contributed to the annual Lindy's Sports Magazine ahead of the 2023 offseason. Daniel is a co-host on the 404TheFalcon podcast and previously wrote for the Around the Block Network and Georgia Sports Hospitality Media.