Scouting TE James Mitchell

SI All Lions provides its scouting report on Detroit Lions rookie tight end James Mitchell.
In this story:

The Lions rolled the proverbial dice, and landed tight end James Mitchell in the fifth round of the 2022 NFL Draft.

Why was Mitchell a roll of the dice? 

It is because Mitchell is a wild card in the world of scouting.

He is a player who probably would have gone way before the fifth round, had it not been for the torn ACL he suffered early last season.

Mitchell only played in two games and caught five passes, and then the knee injury happened.

He played in 20 games during the two seasons prior. The highlights from his college statistics were his 16.1 yards-per-catch average and the seven touchdowns he managed to haul in for Virginia Tech.

Mitchell also showed leadership characteristics, as he had been named as a team captain for the 2021 season.

The elephant in the room is Mitchell’s knee and how it will respond when he hits the field for the Lions.

That is anyone’s guess at this point, but Mitchell did tell reporters after he was selected by Detroit that he’s cleared to return to the field in June without restrictions.

One can only imagine that Detroit general manager Brad Holmes must have gotten the green light from the Lions’ medical staff prior to making this pick.

While I am not a huge fan of projecting players based mostly on game film from a couple seasons ago, I can say if Mitchell’s knee is right, he may very well turn out to be a steal.

I know that’s a big if, but it’s worth the risk in the fifth round, if you ask me.

If it was the first few rounds, I would not be nearly as excited about the pick. But, in the fifth round, to potentially get a second-third-round talent makes sense.

Yes, Mitchell looked that good as a receiving tight end dating back to his 2020 game film. I wasn’t crazy about him as a blocker, however. 

With the departure of veteran tight end Darren Fells, there is ample opportunity to step up and become starter T.J. Hockenson’s backup.

Sitting on the Lions’ depth chart right now behind Hockenson is Brock Wright

In 2021, Wright managed to put up a meager 12 catches for 117 yards and two touchdowns.

I’d say there is a real opportunity for Mitchell to step up and become the No. 2 tight end in Detroit. 

Detroit Lions tight end James Mitchell
© Kirthmon F. Dozier / USA TODAY NETWORK

#82 James Mitchell - 6-foot-3, 242 pounds

2021 game film reviewed: Middle Tennessee (missed most of the season)

2020 game film reviewed: North Carolina and North Carolina State

Grade: C+

Scouting Report

Athletic and fluid, big-framed tight end, with good receiving skills, who works at run blocking. On pass plays, releases methodically into the short-to-intermediate route levels. His basketball background shows when shielding out defenders from the ball. Catches using his hands. Competitive and not the easiest to bring down after the catch. Works for additional yardage, and can make a defender miss in the open field. Excels down the seams, at the intermediate route level. Showed some nifty and polished route running. Can stretch a defense. Showed good concentration. Even took a couple handoffs in the backfield, and scored one TD. 

An adequate run blocker who gave the effort. More of a hold-the-point positional blocker who uses his hands, but relies more on leverage (hook blocks on the edge) to get the job done. A solid-looking, well-rounded prospect.

When I watched Mitchell play, former longtime NFL tight end Fred Baxter came to mind. 

Will he be that good?

Time will tell, but I am thinking Mitchell has a really good chance of beating out Wright and making this team (if he can stay healthy). 


Published
Daniel Kelly
DANIEL KELLY

Daniel spent four years in pro scouting with the New York Jets and brings vast experience scouting pro and college talent.  Daniel has appeared in many major publications, including the New York Times and USA Today.  Author of Whatever it Takes, the true story of a fan making it into the NFL, which was published in 2013. He has appeared on podcasts around the world breaking down and analyzing the NFL. Currently writes for SI All Lions. Can be contacted at whateverittakesbook@gmail.com