New Coach, Same Outcome for Red Wings

The Detroit Red Wings will be no better off with the hiring of their new head coach.

Jan 22, 2023; Chicago, Illinois, USA; Los Angeles Kings head coach Todd McLellan gestures to the referee after a penalty call during the third period at United Center. Mandatory Credit: David Banks-Imagn Images / David Banks-Imagn Images

The Detroit Red Wings announced the inevitable with the firing of head coach Derek Lalonde. The team showed life at the start of his tenure and even improved to 41 wins last season. But this year was a noticeable plateau under Lalonde, and Detroit made the only call they could.

In Lalonde's place, the Red Wings hired Todd McLellan. The former San Jose Sharks, Edmonton Oilers, and Los Angeles Kings coach has over 15 years of NHL head coaching experience, and Detroit is hoping he can bring the team back to the postseason. It's a gamble worth taking for the Red Wings organization, but the outcome won't change as long as the roster construction remains the same.

McLellan is a good coach. He's certainly an improvement over Lalonde, bringing more career wins and nine playoff appearances across three organizations, but he's a band-aid. The wound in the Red Wings organization runs much deeper than who is behind the bench, and McLellan will be the next bench boss to fall victim to the lack of talent in Detroit

The Red Wings haven't made the postseason since the 2015-2016 campaign. Long gone is the 30 year stretch where they were basically a perennial playoff team, capturing four Stanley Cups since 1996. The organization has been attempting to rebuild that dynasty for the last decade, with repeated failures along the way.

The current attempt to build the right core is another one of those missteps. They have good players. Captain Dylan Larkin will be a member of the United States roster for the 4 Nations Face-Off and is a talented point producer. Lucas Raymond continues to improve and become the team's best offensive player. Alex DeBrincat has speed and scoring capabilities. Top defensemen Moritz Seider and Simon Edvinsson give them quality minutes every night.

Beyond them, though, the roster is so far from a playoff one, let alone a championship one. They lack depth across every position and they've consistently failed with their analysis of goaltenders. For several seasons now, the organization has been banking on their overflow of young prospects breaking through to the NHL, but it's still a waiting game.

That won't help McLellan take this middling team to the postseason. He has some weapons to work with and his arrival is sure to reinvigorate the Red Wings players. It ultimately won't matter though. It won't change the outcome this year or next year or even the year after until their NHL lineup improves drastically.

Make sure you bookmark Breakaway On SI for the latest news, exclusive interviews, recruiting coverage, and more!

• Red Wings Make Coaching Change, Hire Veteran
• Devils Forward Nearing Superstar Status
• Avalanche Named Landing Spot for Blue Jackets Defenseman
• Canadiens, Maple Leafs Could Make Rare Rivalry Trade
• Lightning Have Options for New Backup Goalie