Max Scherzer Signs One-Year, $15.5 Million Deal with Toronto Blue Jays: Fantasy Baseball Takeaways
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/7c9ad/7c9ad630b91bad3a2fe8f05059e29f64ed80f2fc" alt="Former Texas Rangers P Max Scherzer Former Texas Rangers P Max Scherzer"
When trying to compete for a World Series title against the cash printing Dodgers, the rest of baseball has to look behind every door for possible help to complete for a championship title. The Blue Jays signed Max Scherzer to a one-year deal for $15.5 million, hoping to capture a line from a hit country song by Toby Keith – As Good as I Once Was.
Blue Jays, RHP Max Scherzer reportedly agree to deal, per @MLBNetwork insider @JonHeyman. pic.twitter.com/bjIHCjSmgA
— MLB (@MLB) January 30, 2025
Scherzer still checks the command bucket based on his walk rate (2.1) over short innings (43.1) in 2024, but home runs (seven) and a lower strikeout rate (8.3 – 10.7 in his career) invite more down days. Last year, he missed time with back, thumb, arm fatigue, shoulder, and hamstring issues. Everything about last season suggested the end was near and age had finally caught up to him. His fastball (92.6 mph) was the lowest of his career and he was more of a hinderance than an asset to fantasy baseball rosters.
The Blue Jay invited Scherzer to one last dance, and the line they need playing in the background is "I ain’t good as I once was, but I’m as good once as I ever was…every five days." The veteran is an intriguing bounce-back candidate heading into the 2025 fantasy baseball season.
With a little more life on his fastball and a bounce in his health, Scherzer has the secondary pitches to get batters out. He is absolutely worthy of a roster spot in 2025 fantasy baseball leagues. Fantasy owners will be hoping for a Chris Sale-like campaign from the veteran in Toronto. Scherzer's resume suggests that he still has upside, particuarly at his current ADP of 382 in the National Fantasy Baseball Championships.
Recommended Articles
Top 5 Catchers for the 2025 Fantasy Baseball Season