Mailbag: Wawrinka's one-hand backhand, Nick Saviano, more mail

MELBOURNE -- Five thoughts from Day ten at the Australian Open: • Madison Keys reached her first Grand Slam semifinal with a strange and injury-addled win over
Mailbag: Wawrinka's one-hand backhand, Nick Saviano, more mail
Mailbag: Wawrinka's one-hand backhand, Nick Saviano, more mail /

MELBOURNE -- Five thoughts from Day ten at the Australian Open:

• Madison Keys reached her first Grand Slam semifinal with a strange and injury-addled win over Venus Williams, 6-3, 4-6, 6-4. The good news: Keys showed fight to match her ferocious power, winning despite an adductor injury. The bad news: with no day off between her semifinal, Keys will be lucky just to get on court tomorrow for her semifinal date against Serena Williams.

Madison Keys beats Venus Williams to advance to her first Slam semifinal

• Every now and then, tennis gets it right. Venus Williams’ play this tournament is one of those times. She reached her first Grand Slam quarterfinal in almost a half-decade this week; and the sport was better for it. Today, though, she came out flatter than a Foxboro football; and never inflated. She moved sluggishly, served poorly, missed dozens of shots and couldn’t take advantage of a hobbled opponent. For four rounds, she looked like a contender to win. On Wednesday, sadly, she did not.

• By contrast, the book on Serena Williams: if you're going to beat her, beat her early in the tournament. No one did and now she has caught a gear, as they say, thoroughly dominating Dominika Cibulkova on Wednesday afternoon. Serena claims to be ill, but her game was in full health today. Oh, and her career record in Grand Slam semifinals? 22-3.

Djokovic cruises to semis, Keys makes her first and more Day 10 results

• For a defending champion, Stan Wawrinka has advanced through the draw with remarkable little fanfare. He continued his run with a stellar straight set defeat over Kei Nishikori.

• As I write this, Novak Djokovic is two sets up on Milos Raonic. No one has said anything openly, but you get a distinct sense that the Old Guard—the Big Four plus Wawrinka—isn't quite ready to surrender ground to the next generation of Dimitrov, Nishikori, and Raonic -- and we can add Nick Kyrgios to the list.

Mailbag

Why are the players looking way up in the interviews?  
-- @Jjmulherin

Simple: the interview room here is, perversely, designed like a college lecture hall. The inquiring masses sit above the subject and angle their questions downward. Inasmuch as the players seek to make eye contact with their interrogators, they must look up.

For discussion: Nick Saviano is a “value investor.” He understands the concept of “buy low, sell high.”

12 things you should know about 19-year-old American Madison Keys

Not bad. Saviano worked Genie Bouchard last year —a year in which she went from a bright prospect to a bona fide star. He is now with Sloane Stephens, which is akin to owning a stock that shot up and has since corrected. Long as we’re here, I’m curious about another former Saviano, Laura Robson, who is due back on tour soon. Wrist injuries are no joke—that, we know. But Robson turned 21 this week, and there is still plenty of time for potential filling.

The tennis GRE analogytest.
Wawrinka-Nadal in 2014 Australian Open:

A.  Safin-Sampras in 2000 U.S. Open -- a talented player, without the focus/ambition to succeed consistently, who ultimately underachieves

B.  Mauresmo-Henin in 2006 Aussie Open -- a very good, but not great player, who was simply outshone by a bevy of more gifted players in her generation

C:  Johansson-Safin in 2002 Aussie Open -- a good player who caught lightening in a bottle for two weeks, and defeated an opponent who on any other day was more likely have outclassed him
-- Questioner name misplaced by overworked, underorganized Mailbag writer

Well, I feel sheepish answering so long as Wawrinka remains in the tournament. In the event he defends his title, we will come to view his original 2014 title in a different light. But my initial response is “B.”

Thomas Johansson really came out of nowhere. We’re talking about a guy who made only one other Grand Slam semifinal and—even after winning a Slam—never entered the top five.  Wawrinka, by contrast, had just reached the 2013 U.S. Open semis in his previous major and was fifth with the oddsmakers before last year’s event even started.

As for “A” I don’t think of Wawrinka as a talent squanderer; I think of him as a very, very good player in an era the demand greatness.

Does Stan have the most powerful one-handed backhand? Amalgro maybe? Maybe Fed's was too but remember it as more graceful than this
-- @MistrDaniel

Australian Open Fashion Hits and Misses

HIT: Maria Sharapova

461762504_10.jpg
Clive Brunskill/Getty Images

In a sea of neon, Sharapova's classy pink number hits all the right notes.

HIT: Sharapova

461759642_10.jpg
Ryan Pierse/Getty Images

MISS: Victoria Azarenka's long sleeve

461939942_10.jpg
Wayne Taylor/Getty Images

Rule No. 1 in tennis fashion: Don't dress like the tennis ball.

HIT: Grigor Dimitrov

461744414_10.jpg
Patrick Scala/Getty Images

Black, white, clean -- the best men's kit of 2015.

HIT: Dimitrov

461865036_10.jpg
Mark Kolbe/Getty Images

HIT: Andy Murray

461990156_10.jpg
Wayne Taylor/Getty Images

Murray wears the black and bright green combo well, and it's a bit more subdued than some of the other neon colors.

MISS: Venus Williams

462047796_10.jpg
Wayne Taylor/Getty Images

2014 was a great year for Venus' EleVen, but their first offering this year is an ill-fitting 70's inspired mess.

MISS: Venus

462045064_10.jpg
MANAN VATSYAYANA/AFP/Getty Images

HIT: Roger Federer

461993998_10.jpg
Cameron Spencer/Getty Images

It's a rare sight to see Federer in fluorescent colors. And rarer still, after his third round loss.

HIT: Roger Federer

461990662_10.jpg
Cameron Spencer/Getty Images

HIT: Petra Kvitova

461934546_10.jpg
Clive Brunskill/Getty Images

Looking as fit as ever, Kvitova has been wearing this pink Nike kit well.

HIT: Kvitova

461932050_10.jpg
MANAN VATSYAYANA/AFP/Getty Images

HIT: Eugenie Bouchard

461987044_10.jpg
Cameron Spencer/Getty Images

Youthful and fresh in pink.

HIT: Madison Keys

461932306_10.jpg
Michael Dodge/Getty Images

Just like Bouchard, Nike made the right choice with this hot pink number.

HIT: Ana Ivanovic

461746964_10.jpg
Ryan Pierse/Getty Images

Blink and you missed it.

MISS: Kei Nishikori

461927078_10.jpg
Ryan Pierse/Getty Images

The lime green color somehow looks old and dirty. Uniqlo would have been better off with something clean and bright.

HIT: Elina Svitolina

461931694_10.jpg
Quinn Rooney/Getty Images

A classic tennis look from a classic tennis brand in Ellesse.

HIT: Elina Svitolina

461809066_10.jpg
Clive Brunskill/Getty Images

HIT: Agnieszka Radwanska

461809028_10.jpg
Patrick Scala/Getty Images

Clean and fresh in Lotto.

MISS: Caroline Wozniacki

461939938_10.jpg
Wayne Taylor/Getty Images

The fit is perfect, but the color and pattern are reminiscent of an old tea towel.

MISS: Caroline Wozniacki

461805266_10.jpg
Michael Dodge/Getty Images

HIT: Rafael Nadal's shorts

462004268_10.jpg
Cameron Spencer/Getty Images

Nadal called them his "party pants."

HIT: Nadal

462004324_10.jpg
Quinn Rooney/Getty Images

HIT: Milos Raonic

461944928_10.jpg
Robert Prezioso/Getty Images

The neon stripe on the socks makes it work.

HIT: Serena Williams

461810054_10.jpg
Michael Dodge/Getty Images

The dream of the 80s is alive in Melbourne. If only she had some leg warmers.

HIT: Serena

461925310_10.jpg
Clive Brunskill/Getty Images

HIT: Serena

462051270_10.jpg
Ryan Pierse/Getty Images

We loved the back detail on the dress as well.

HIT: Simona Halep

461744264_10.jpg
Clive Brunskill/Getty Images

A no-nonsense athletic look for a no-nonsense athletic star.

HIT: Thanasi Kokkinakis

461765974_10.jpg
Michael Dodge/Getty Images

It's the most memorable kit of the tournament and a look Kokkinakis worked to perfection in his five set win over Gulbis. Winning makes (almost) everything look good.

HIT: Victoria Azarenka's sleeveless

461798654_10.jpg
MAL FAIRCLOUGH/AFP/Getty Images

It's the women's version of Kyrgios' kit. And we like it.

MISS: Novak Djokovic

461804872_10.jpg
Quinn Rooney/Getty Images

Djokovic has been alternating between a white shirt and a blue shirt. A boring and disappointing offer from Uniqlo.

MISS: Dimitrov

461804334_10.jpg
Quinn Rooney/Getty Images

HIT: Dimitrov

461744430_10.jpg
Patrick Scala/Getty Images

MISS: Nishikori

461922508_10.jpg
Ryan Pierse/Getty Images

MISS: Stan Wawrinka

461799470_10.jpg
Cameron Spencer/Getty Images

A boring striped blue shirt? The defending champion deserves better from Yonex.

MISS: Andrea Petkovic

461808268_10.jpg
Patrick Scala/Getty Images

The grey top is great. The skirt is cute too. But put them together and it's a mess.

MISS: Simone Bolelli

461864448_10.jpg

Military camo? Really?

MISS: Muguruza

461796922_10.jpg
WILLIAM WEST/AFP/Getty Images

The kit doesn't work on Muguruza, either.

MISS: Bolelli

461861946_10.jpg
Ryan Pierse/Getty Images

MISS: Gael Monfils

461937674_10.jpg
MANAN VATSYAYANA/AFP/Getty Images

Let's put the pumpkin orange away, Asics.

MISS: Monfils

461814948_10.jpg
Mark Kolbe/Getty Images

MISS: Michael Russell

461749268_10.jpg
Wayne Taylor/Getty Images

Worst kit of the tournament.

MISS: Fernando Verdasco

461938558_10.jpg
MAL FAIRCLOUGH/AFP/Getty Images

Is his head rising from the smoke and ashes?

MISS: Tomas Berdych

461990150_10.jpg
Ryan Pierse/Getty Images

In the sea of blue that is the Australian Open, let's not add more blue.

MISS: Berdych

461986402_10.jpg
Ryan Pierse/Getty Images

HIT: Camila Giorgi

AP658224176766.jpg
Andy Brownbill/AP Photo

Shorts! A belt! A collar! This is pretty old school and great.

HIT: Nick Kyrgios

AP847340680411.jpg
Cal Sport Media via AP Images

It's the fluorescent version of Dimitrov's kit and the 19-year-old has lit it up.

We were just talking about this. We can argue over art and stylishness. Eye of the beholder and all that. You say Richard Gasquet. Someone else says Federer or Dimitrov. A reader threw Andrei Pavel’s name out. But for sheer power, we can talk more objectively. I lean toward Wawrinka. He hits over that thing and just crushes the ball.

@jon_wertheim what's wrong with Rafa? Did he look off in his prior matches?
-- @jjcruiser

For the most part, yes. Remember, Nadal was perilously close to losing to Tim Smyczek in round two. (Of course he also looked like the Nadal of old in decisive wins over Mikhail Youzhny and Kevin Anderson, both creditable opponents.

Tomas Berdych stuns Rafael Nadal in Australian Open quarterfinals

This is both a blessing and curse, but the mores on contemporary prevent players from mentioning injury in defeat. There is something noble and sporting about this. There is also something disingenuous. During Nadal’s match against Berdych he was noticeably, unmistakably at something other than full speed. At one point, a member of his camp dashed off to find some pills that were then handed to Nadal courtside. At another time, he grimaced and pointed to his hip. Before we starting burying Nadal and the never-win-another-Slam buzzards begin circling the carrion, don't discount that he was clearly injured on Tuesday.

Broader point: for each match, there is a balance we all undertake, praising the victor versus dissecting the loser. In the case of Berdych-Nadal, we shouldn't on stint of praise for Berdych. He played authoritative tennis, competed better and kept his nerve in a third-set tiebreaker. But anyone who has watched Nadal, even casually, knows that he was far, far from his best this event.


Published
Jon Wertheim
JON WERTHEIM

Jon Wertheim is a senior writer for Sports Illustrated and has been part of the full-time SI writing staff since 1997, largely focusing on the tennis beat , sports business and social issues, and enterprise journalism. In addition to his work at SI, he is a correspondent for "60 Minutes" and a commentator for The Tennis Channel. He has authored 11 books and has been honored with two Emmys, numerous writing and investigative journalism awards, and the Eugene Scott Award from the International Tennis Hall of Fame. Wertheim is a longtime member of the New York Bar Association (retired), the International Tennis Writers Association and the Writers Guild of America. He has a bachelor's in history from Yale University and received a law degree from the University of Pennsylvania. He resides in New York City with his wife, who is a divorce mediator and adjunct law professor. They have two children.