Bama in the NFL: Can You Name Alabama's Only All-Pro With The New York Giants?

One league's longest-established franchises has had plenty of former Crimson Tide players on the roster, but only two who were named to Pro Bowl.

The New York Giants seem to have a good history with former Alabama Crimson Tide players, at least on face value. 

Heading into the 2023 season, there have been 27 players who have suited up and played for the Giants, one of the proudest franchises in the NFL. Among them, four won a Super Bowl including tight end Howard Cross, who has had the longest career among those from the Crimson Tide, playing in New York from 1989-2001. 

Then you look a little closer, and some other things become apparent. For example, of those 27 players, only one other played for the Giants for more than five years: Jeff Rutledge from 1983-89, as the backup quarterback.

In 1953, the Giants used a first-round draft pick on a player from Alabama, running back Bobby Marlow with the eighth-overall selection. Yet he never played in the NFL, instead opting for the  Canadian Football League's Saskatchewan Roughriders, and went on to tally 4,291 rushing yards on 833 attempts and 34 touchdowns. The Giants waited 69 yards before selecting another Crimson Tide player in the first round, tackle Evan Neal in 2022.

Consequently, there's only been one Alabama player who has had an All-Pro season with the Giants, Landon Collins in 2016. 

The safety was a unanimous All-American at Alabama in 2014, but surprisingly slid into the second round of the 2015 NFL Draft, when the Giants traded up to get him with the first pick (33rd overall). He suffered a sprained MCL in a preseason game, but only missed one more, and won a starting job at free safety.

He switched back to his natural position, strong safety, for this second year and Collins responded by being the only player in NFL history to have 100-plus tackles, more than two sacks, at least five interceptions, and at least 12 pass deflections in a season (specifically, and respectfully, he had 125, four, five and 13 in 16 starts). Collins was named the NFC Defensive Player of the Month for November, when tallied 30 tackles, a sack and three picks.

He was subsequently ranked 28th by his peers in the NFL Top 100, and voted to the Pro Bowl for the first of three-straight times. The only other former Crimson Tide player to make the Pro Bowl was one of the program's most interesting and colorful linemen, Art "Tarzan" White back in 1938. He earned his doctorate at Columbus University in 1939 while with the Giants, and later went into professional wrestling and was twice the world heavyweight champion. 

As for Cross, he caught 201 passes for 2,194 yards and 17 touchdowns over 13 seasons. That's over 207 games played, compared to just one missed, after being a sixth-round draft pick.  

Bama in the NFL: New York Giants

The Franchise

National Football Conference

East Division 

Team Colors: Blue, Red and White

Founded: 1925, legally named "New York Football Giants"

Stadium: MetLife Stadium (capacity 82,500)

Playing Surface: FieldTurf Core

Training Camp: Quest Diagnostics Training Center, East Rutherford, NJ

All-Time Alabama Players

1. Clarence "Butch" Avinger, RB, 1953
2. Jim Bowdoin, OG, 1932
3. Steve Bowman, RB, 1966
4. Dave Brown, RB, 1943, 1946 - 1947
5. Jeremy Clark, DT, 2008
6. Landon Collins, DB, 2015 - 2018, 2022
7. Howard Cross, TE, 1989 - 2001
8. D.J. Fluker, OT, 2017
9. Cornelius Griffin, DT, 2000 - 2003
10. Herb Hannah, OT, 1951
11. Nico Johnson, LB, 2015
12. Robbie Jones, LB, 1984 - 1987
13. Frank Martin, HB, 1945
14. Ken MacAfee, TE/OE, 1954 - 1958
15. Curtis McGriff, DE, 1980 - 1985
16. Xavier McKinney, S, 2020 - 2022
17. Evan Neal, OT, 2022
18. Reggie Ragland, LB, 2021
19. Jeff Rutledge, QB, 1983 - 1989
20. Billy Shipp, OT, 1954
21. George Thornton, DT, 1993
22. Dalvin Tomlinson, DT, 2017 - 2020
23. Bob Trocolor, QB/RB, 1942 - 1943
24. Bull Wesley, C/OG, 1928
25. Art "Tarzan" White, OG, 1937 - 1939, 1945
26. Butch Wilson, TE, 1968 - 1969
27. Steve Wright, OT, 1968 - 1969

Crimson Tide Drafted Players

Year	Player	Pos.	Round	Pick	Overall
1937	Arthur "Tarzan" White	G	2	4	14
1943	Dave Brown	B	25	6	236
1944	Andy Bires	E	27	5	279
1945	John Staples	G	32	5	329
1946	Nick Terlizzi	T	16	5	145
1949	Pat O'Sullivan	C	20	4	195
1951	Herb Hannah	T	6	11	73
1952	Billy Shipp	T	8	10	95
1953	Bobby Marlow	B	1	8	8
1959	Dave Sington	T	30	10	358
1966	Steve Bowman	RB	15	11	226
1967	Louis Thompson	DT	4	2	82
1974	Buddy Brown	G	16	2	392
1980	Ken Harris	RB	8	7	200
1983	Robbie Jones	LB	12	2	309
1989	Howard Cross	TE	6	19	158
1995	Bryne Diehl	P	7	17	225
2000	Cornelius Griffin	DT	2	11	42
2006	Charlie Peprah	S	5	26	158
2015	Landon Collins	S	2	1	33
2017	Dalvin Tomlinson	DT	2	23	55
2020	Xavier McKinney	S	2	4	36
2022	Evan Neal	T	1	7	7

Super Bowl Appearances

Super Bowl XXI (Jan. 25, 1987)

Backup quarterback Jeff Rutledge helped spark the strong second half when he came on the field to be a decoy in punt formation on fourth-and-1. When the Broncos didn't pay him him any attention, he lined up under center and ran a quarterback draw for a first down. The drive ended with a field, but the Giants scored touchdowns on each of their next four possessions to win going away, 39-20. Linebacker Robbie Jones was credited with one tackle and defensive end Curtis McGriff was also on the Giants.

Super Bowl XXV (Jan. 27, 1991)

Every time Howard Cross had a reception, the Giants ended up scoring. The tight end finished with four for 39 yards as New York held on to win 20-19 against the Bills. It's the only Super Bowl decided by one point, and was the first Super Bowl in which neither team committed a turnover. 

Buffalo Bills cornerback Nate Odomes (37) attempts to tackle New York Giants tight end Howard Cross (87) during Super Bowl XXV at Tampa Stadium / USA TODAY Sports

Super Bowl XXXV (Jan. 28, 2001)

Cornelius Griffin had 1.5 sacks and Cross had one catch for 7 yards, but the Giants just didn't match up against Ozzie Newsome's Baltimore Ravens won their first Super Bowl title, 34-7.  

Major Awards/Honors

All-Pro

Landon Collins (1): 2016

Pro Bowl 

Landon Collins (3): 2016, 2017, 2018

Art "Tarzan" White (1): 1938

In conjunction with our revamped Bama in the NFL Database, this is the 24th story in a series examining the team-by-team history of Alabama's former players in the NFL.

AFC

• Baltimore Ravens
• Buffalo Bills
• Cincinnati Bengals
• Cleveland Browns
• Denver Broncos
• Houston Texans
• Indianapolis Colts
• Jacksonville Jaguars
• Kansas City Chiefs
• Las Vegas Raiders
• Los Angeles Chargers
• Miami Dolphins
• New England Patriots

NFC

• Arizona Cardinals
• Atlanta Falcons
• Carolina Panthers
• Chicago Bears
• Dallas Cowboys
• Detroit Lions
• Green Bay Packers
• Los Angeles Rams
• Minnesota Vikings
• New Orleans Saints

See Also:

Bama in the NFL: The Ultimate Crimson Tide Database
Bama in the NFL: Active Alabama Crimson Tide Players by Team