Cleveland Baseball Insider

Will The Guardians Give James Karinchak A Second Chance?

Terry Francona and Carl Willis both comment that James Karninchak is pitching better in Triple-A, but hold off on confirming a return to the Cleveland Guardians.

Tommy Wild

Will The Guardians Give James Karinchak A Second Chance?
Will The Guardians Give James Karinchak A Second Chance? /
In this story:

Everyone deserves a second chance. Right? That's the mantra we're all told growing up in order never to cut ties with someone even if they haven't been perfect in the past. However, second chances are hard to come by in sports.

The Cleveland Guardians optioned James Karinchak back on June 10 because he struggled with his command and striking out hitters.

The Guardians are currently in quite the predicament as their starting rotation is falling apart and has three rookie arms in it which is putting a massive strain on the bullpen. Even with all of this, the organization has been reluctant to bring Karinchak back to the Majors.

Is there a possibility he gets another opportunity with the team, or has that ship sailed?

Let's start with the stats.

Karinchak held a 3.90 ERA over 32 appearances before his demotion to the minors. Since then, he's pitched in 11 games while posting a 2.38 ERA. This includes 21 strikeouts and six walks.

Those numbers aren't bad, but what are the coaches saying about him?

Terry Francona mentioned on Monday that, "By all accounts, (Karinchak) has been pitching pretty well. His velocity has been down, but no issues health-wise."

Pitching coach Carl Willis had a similar evaluation of Karinchak. However, when he was asked if the righty is close to rejoining the team, Willis hesitantly said, "I think he's certainly to a point where if we have a need ... yeah, he's getting close. But again, the need has to be there."

One would think the need for Karinchak is there though. The team has already gone through two bullpen games with the injury to Shane Bieber and it appears more are on the way. 

Both Francona and Willis comment that Karinchak is pitching better, but they're unwilling to give a clear answer on whether we'll see him again with the Guardians this season. It appears we'll just have to wait and see if Karinchak is given that second chance and if the need for him ever comes. 

----

Read More:

Chris Antonetti Explains Guardians' Plan Ahead Of MLB Trade Deadline

Terry Francona Talks About Gabriel Arias' Current Role With Guardians

Josh Bell Still Has More To Give The Guardians

All Eyes On Bryce Harper As Guardians Take Series Opener Over Phillies

Let's Talk About Shohei Ohtani To The Guardians, What A Trade Could Look Like

Be sure to stay locked into Cleveland Baseball Insider all the time:

SUBSCRIBE to the CBI YouTube channel

Follow Cleveland Baseball Insider on Twitter: @CBI_FanNation

Photo Credit © Ken Blaze-USA TODAY Sports

Published
Tommy Wild
TOMMY WILD

Home/News