Derrick Henry's Potential Return in 2024 Will Be About Role as Much as Contract

Tennessee Titans star Derrick Henry will be entering free agency after the season and there is the chance he will not return in 2024, but if there is to be a reunion, it will be about Henry's fit in the offense just as much as the price to bring him back.

The Tennessee Titans could see the end of an era when this season concludes in three weeks. Star running back Derrick Henry is set to become a free agent and there is no certainty he will be brought back. A potential reunion with Henry in 2024 will depend on multiple factors.

Obviously, when discussing any free agent dealings, the biggest factor is the contract. Players want to be paid what they are worth compared to their peers. Henry's case is complicated in this matter, but it may not be the most complicated part.

Henry is still most certainly capable of big games. If he is able to get an open lane to the second level of a defense, he can make smaller player pay with his straight-line speed and strength. On the other side, Henry clearly lacks a quickness at this stage and he has limitations in the passing game. 

Mike Vrabel spoke about this reality with Henry in a very poignant and courteous way on Monday when asked if Henry's days as an elite running back were over after his 20 touch, 10 yard performance against the Texans.

"We understand that Derrick's got a certain running style," Vrabel explained, "great skillset and we have to be able to get him going and give him some space and get him to the second level. He in turn has to be able to help the line, help the receivers, help the tight end. It all goes hand in hand."

"You don't just hand it to a guy and they beat three people, but there's also times where guys make a great cut or guys make a guy miss or Derrick stiff-arms a guy. So, certainly after yesterday, nobody was good enough. Everybody involved."

It is pretty clear that Vrabel is saying Henry needs to make someone miss as much as the offensive line needs to block better. Both problems are real and that is why the Titans cannot treat Henry as the engine of their offensive going forward.

He can't be paid like that and the offense can't be expected to be at it's best when he gets 20 carries a game. It needs to evolve into a more modern offense that is designed around speed on the perimeter and a committee-based approach with versatile backs.

Now, that is not to say that Henry can't have a place. Henry has his strengths and a valuable skillset, but he needs to be used as a tool in the toolbox, not the toolbox itself. Tyjae Spears should be the lead back for this team in 2024 and as long as Henry and the offensive play-caller understand and operate that way, there can still be a beneficial relationship.

That is arguably more important than the price tag, but money will always be a factor. If Henry is willing to agree and the Titans agree as well, then the next step will be the contract. Right now, Henry's market projection is $9.5 million per season according to Spotrac.com and that is simply too high.

I personally doubt we see Henry get that kind of money this offseason from anyone, but it certainly can't be the Titans. With the slew of serviceable veterans and a sea of potential rookies that could easily be part of a Spears-led committee, you can find contributors that would be significantly cheaper. 

Would you rather have Henry and Spears for $11.5 million or Spears and Zack Moss for $6 million? That answer should be simple at this stage and Moss is just one name of many. Another rookie with Spears could cost as little as $2 million total.

This would give the Titans more money to spend on positions that are more difficult to find talent at, that they also happened to desperately need. Wide receiver, offensive line and the secondary could all use major upgrades. Upgrades you might be able to afford if you don't spend $10 million on Henry.

So, if Henry agrees to a reduced role and will sign for somewhere near the $6 million mark, a reunion could be possible and could lead to Henry finally eclipsing 10,000 career rushing yards and 100 touchdowns while wearing a Titans jersey his entire career. 

Related stories on Titans-Texans

• LEVIS SHOULD SIT: The Tennessee Titans not only lost any chance at the playoffs by losing to the Houston Texans in Week 15, but they also saw their rookie quarterback get injured. If the Titans are smart, they will sit Will Levis for the rest of the season in a move that is best for both team and player. CLICK HERE
• TEXANS CLAIM TART: Not only did the Tennessee Titans lose their Week 15 matchup to the Houston Texans, but they'll be losing their starting nose tackle to them as well. After being surprisingly cut by the Titans on Saturday, Teair Tart was claimed by the Texans on Monday. CLICK HERE
• WEEK 15 TITAN UP-TITAN DOWN: The Tennessee Titans didn't have a lot of winners in a soul-crushing loss to the Houston Texans in Week 15, but there were definitely some losers during the madness. CLICK HERE
• LEVIS INJURY UPDATE: The Tennessee Titans' loss to the Houston Texans stung a bit more watching rookie quarterback Will Levis get injured and according to head coach Mike Vrabel, the injury is similar to Tannehill's ankle injury. CLICK HERE
• TITANS LOSE IN OT: The Tennessee Titans lost at home in overtime again, falling to the Houston Texans 19-16 despite having an early 13-point lead. They struggled offensively after their opening scoring drive and fell to 5-9, getting eliminated from the postseason. CLICK HERE